Grex Coop Conference

Item 275: Dial-in Lines

Entered by mary on Mon Apr 12 22:34:20 2010:

52 new of 115 responses total.


#64 of 115 by dropcap on Fri Apr 23 06:45:07 2010:

sindi, do you ever use vim/?



#65 of 115 by cross on Fri Apr 23 14:19:50 2010:

resp:63 I seriously think that you're the only one who wants to.


#66 of 115 by keesan on Fri Apr 23 15:29:20 2010:

Sounds like nobody is willing to try to make Pine print directly in linux.
I use pico or nano.  I have tried vi and some day will really learn it.
I also can't use fronttalk from Windows or even Puppy Linux (ssh or telnet)
unless I ssh from grex to sdf and back.


#67 of 115 by lar on Fri Apr 23 15:36:49 2010:

get a real system with a good connection and your problems are over.


#68 of 115 by rcurl on Fri Apr 23 20:38:26 2010:

I do recall printing directly from pine many computers, systems, and
connections ago. I can't recall how it is done. But since you can do anything
with Linux, you should be able to write a script to print from pine (I
couldn't, though). 


#69 of 115 by keesan on Fri Apr 23 21:00:09 2010:

Can anyone print with %?  I am not a linux programmer.  


#70 of 115 by tod on Fri Apr 23 23:55:38 2010:

I don't have any messages in my inbox to print so I can't test it


#71 of 115 by keesan on Sat Apr 24 01:42:48 2010:

You could email yourself a message.  Is there some way to print directly from
home directory?


#72 of 115 by tonster on Sat Apr 24 03:28:26 2010:

You could try setting your terminal to vt100 as well and seeing if that
worked.


#73 of 115 by keesan on Sat Apr 24 13:50:49 2010:

My terminal is set to vt100.  I also tried linux.  


#74 of 115 by tonster on Sat Apr 24 15:07:55 2010:

You said earlier your terminal type was set to linux, now you said it's
vt100.  Which is it?


#75 of 115 by keesan on Sat Apr 24 17:07:16 2010:

I have used both.  I messed up a file (.login?, .cshrc?) and copied over Jim's
fresh one which was set to vt100 recently.  Neither lets me print in linux.
Or use fronttalk from Windows or Puppy Linux telnet or ssh.  


#76 of 115 by glitch on Mon May 3 05:08:44 2010:

Long-time user and BBS lurker here...I started with Grex years ago when it
ran on Sun hardware -- my first experience with UNIX. I still use the dialins
now and then...I believe last time was from a 1200 baud modem connected to
an Apple IIe a few months ago (it's usually more often when I'm not off at
college). I'll be sad to see the dialins go, but if usage is that low, I agree
that they should be terminated. If nothing else, I can connect to my Linux
box via null modem cable and telnet/ssh to Grex.


#77 of 115 by mary on Mon May 3 14:15:43 2010:

Thanks for the feedback (and understanding), glitch.


#78 of 115 by lar on Mon May 3 14:31:18 2010:

<burp>


#79 of 115 by saeger on Wed May 5 04:07:31 2010:

The dialup lines and Lynx are the reasons I joined GREX.  It's the only way
I can connect to the internet on my 286.  I used this as my only computer for
years untill my living situation changed.  I curently connect via a laptop
with WIFI.  In a few months I will be moving once again and will return to
using my 286.  In my current living situation I cannot connect via dialup
because I am without a landline phone.  I would be VERY dissapointed to see
dialup access droped.  If the lines recive low useage I would recomend droping
one of the lines instead of both. Although I can recall times when I had to
dial the seconed number because the first was busy.  Dialup access is
important, it's what sets GREX apart from the other remaning BBS's.


#80 of 115 by rcurl on Wed May 5 04:22:34 2010:

Perhaps those wanting the dialup should get together and agree to pay for it?
What's wrong with using your laptop and scapping the 286?


#81 of 115 by keesan on Wed May 5 14:17:26 2010:

Probably saeger is moving some placed without free wifi access.
If it is some place in Michigan, get a free dialup account with dialinfree,
and outside of Michigan someone mentioned another free dialup service.
There are also cheap services.  vt.isp was $4/month last I knew.
Rane and I are among the last people to use grex dialup and I have not
done so for a few months now.  


#82 of 115 by kentn on Wed May 5 18:16:32 2010:

The problems we have with the dialup lines are: 1. not enough usage
and 2. not enough money coming in to pay for them.  If we still had dozens
of users with memberships to pay for them, it wouldn't be an issue to keep
them.  But right now, we're slowly but surely going broke, so dropping
this on-going cost is one thing we can do to slow down that slide.
As others have mentioned, there are alternatives for dial-in (and free
ones to boot).  If, by some odd chance, dial-up modems come back into
vogue and there is a great demand for the lines, we can discuss putting
them back in. But I rather doubt we will see that demand. 
 
If someone (or a group of someones) wants to pay the monthly cost of a
line, we could discuss that as an alternative to removal.


#83 of 115 by rcurl on Wed May 5 20:39:41 2010:

I haven't used dialup - anywhere - for years. I don't even have a modem that
will work with any of my computers. 


#84 of 115 by tod on Wed May 5 20:48:29 2010:

http://www.google.com/support/forum/p/voice/thread?tid=0c71b883aeab0711&hl=
en


#85 of 115 by kentn on Thu May 6 03:31:37 2010:

Re 83: same for me.  Well, I do have an external modem I could use, but I've
a got decent download speed from the cable company, so no need to use it.


#86 of 115 by glitch on Fri May 7 20:20:37 2010:

What would maintaining a single dialin cost per month? If it's low enough,
perhaps the few of us who do still use the dialins could pay to keep one of
them up.


#87 of 115 by slynne on Fri May 7 20:32:23 2010:

I don't think it is a lot. Maybe $20/mo per line. So all it would take
to keep one up is $240/year and if there is enough interest, I am sure
the board will consider keeping one around. If that $20/mo is in the
ball park, it would be in grex's best interest to keep a dial up line if
it brings in only four annual memberships. 



#88 of 115 by rcurl on Fri May 7 21:12:42 2010:

Shouldn't the "fee" for dialups be in addition to the general dues?


#89 of 115 by slynne on Fri May 7 21:17:55 2010:

It depends. If grex can get 4 or more additional memberships (i.e
memberships that grex would not otherwise get) because of a dial up line
then it would make sense to keep it. 

why? 12 mos x $20 = $240  and 4 x $60 = $240


#90 of 115 by mary on Fri May 7 21:53:10 2010:

A single line residential line is $39 and change, after taxes and fees.  
If I see Mark Conger tomorrow I'll ask about Grex's phone bill.


#91 of 115 by keesan on Fri May 7 22:14:46 2010:

My residential phone line is $29 including fees and taxes.  Ask Mark to
contact us about a reel-to-reel tape deck Jim fixed for him to use.  


#92 of 115 by kentn on Fri May 7 22:18:40 2010:

Thanks, Mary.  

If we could get usage statistics from the last 6 months that'd give us a
better idea of actual usage.  What we've heard up to now is that usage
is so abysmally low (24 minutes in one month) that it doesn't justify
paying for the lines or having the staff potentially spend time to keep
them working for dialup.  Even if the lines were paid for, we'd still
require staff to maintain them (such as previous discussion of better
modems).

Can staff give us such a report?  Or are we limited to just the last
month?


#93 of 115 by slynne on Sat May 8 01:49:52 2010:

resp:90 Is that because Grex is not eligible for the $19.75 residential
plan advertised on ATT's web site?


#94 of 115 by rcurl on Sat May 8 04:38:58 2010:

I bet that's for 6 months...

Re #89: that just pays for the dialin - it doesn't support the rest of Grex,
which the dialins would still be using.


#95 of 115 by mary on Sat May 8 10:52:11 2010:

I'd like to hear from someone who comes in on dialup (or has a modem) if 
dialinfree works.  If it does, cool, it's time to make the move.  If it 
doesn't, we'll have to decide whether we can afford to maintain even one 
line for so few users.

I really don't want to move into anyone paying for a specific service.  
That just seems wrong and then puts us into contract mode where we're 
obligated to support this access, possible ahead of everything else our 
volunteer staff has to cover.


#96 of 115 by slynne on Sat May 8 13:08:05 2010:

resp:94 I guess but I pay around $30 for my land line and I have a lot
of features grex doesn't need. I suspect there is probably a different
pricing structure for business vs residential customers. 

Regardless, if it is more like $40/mo than the marginal increase in
memberships per year would have to be 8. I thought 4 would be a stretch.
I don't think 8 is very likely. 

I agree with Mary that outright charging people for dial up service is
probably a bad idea. 


#97 of 115 by keesan on Sat May 8 15:50:10 2010:

I pay $29 without any features.  I have been using dialinfree with grex for
years now.


#98 of 115 by kentn on Sat May 8 19:44:05 2010:

As a non-profit, we can take donations with a purpose and put them
toward a service.  It does not need to be seen as charging people for a
service.

If we do try to get a new machine and use it as fund-raiser, that would
be no different.  


#99 of 115 by cyklone on Sat May 8 21:03:52 2010:

I doubt the costs associated with "maintaining" dialup access are all
that great in terms of time and money. If a subgroup of users are
willing to cover the costs, then I can't see any good reason for grex to
ignore such efforts by that group.


#100 of 115 by glitch on Sun May 9 02:37:00 2010:

I'd certainly be willing to become a full, paying member if it'd help keep
the dialins up -- my girlfriend and I use them when we're traveling and can't
get to a free Internet connection, since many of our relatives live out in
the country. While I'm geographically distant from the actual servers, I'd
also be willing to donate time in keeping the dialin managed.


#101 of 115 by keesan on Sun May 9 03:46:26 2010:

Do your relatives live in Michigan?  One month's membership is only $5 or $6,
not enough for one phone line.


#102 of 115 by rcurl on Sun May 9 04:32:45 2010:

If you get enough users donating to cover the cost of one dialin connection,
won't they have frequent conflicts of use, and perhaps find the service
unsatisfactory for that reason?


#103 of 115 by glitch on Sun May 9 05:00:04 2010:

@101: no, but i've generated a script for minicom that allows the use of a
calling card with dialins. Usually you're stuck with lower speeds, but for
signing in to check e-mail and such it's fine.

With as little dialin access as has been reported, I wouldn't think that there
would be enough use to make a single line inconvenient. Even if two people
called at the same time, with 24 min/month, you'd just have to wait a few
minutes and call again.


#104 of 115 by mary on Sun May 9 10:21:12 2010:

Mark said Grex's phone bill comes to between $50 and $60 a month, for the 
two lines.  


#105 of 115 by keesan on Sun May 9 15:34:54 2010:

Can you instead of calling grex using TCP/IP and call dialinfree?


#106 of 115 by glitch on Tue May 11 21:43:15 2010:

Sure, I can call through a free dialup service, but it's often faster to
connect directly to grex due to poor connection quality out in the country.

I've put the word out to see if there's any interests in subscribed
memberships on a few of the Internet forums I frequent. Both of them have a
strong vintage computer following, so they're the sort of people who are
likely to be interested in dialin public UNIX (many of them use SDF).


#107 of 115 by cross on Sun Jul 11 14:40:13 2010:

Another issue with maintaining dialin lines is that it makes moving to a
 virtualized hardware solution somewhat more difficult.


#108 of 115 by lar on Sun Jul 11 15:19:58 2010:

there's cross...fuck you richard


#109 of 115 by madmike on Mon Jul 12 02:58:43 2010:

Remember dial-up BBS? Notice the "Remember" at the beginning of this
post? Seems like a no-brainer to me. (but I get that alot)

Are the dial in lines supposed to be to allow free internet access? or
free access to grex? If I needed to connect to grex via dial-up it would
not be free for me. I think if grex is going to keep dial in lines it
should also offer a toll free number or frankly, I don't get it.

If it is just a service for Local residents of Ann Arbor then it can all
go back to someones basement (and their dreams.) What _was_ the dream
anyway?


#110 of 115 by tsty on Tue Jul 20 04:53:07 2010:

  
att ahs yet to resppod .. grrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr
  


#111 of 115 by tsty on Fri Jul 23 23:24:09 2010:

  
att has responded ... in theory (he siad) the 2nd line is no w toast.
  


#112 of 115 by tsty on Sat Jul 24 06:37:35 2010:

  
howeer, as jsut noted in another item, the line stil answers with
modem noixes ... but, accordint to the rep, the billing has stopped.
  
we shall see


#113 of 115 by tsty on Sat Jul 31 22:04:02 2010:

  
we saw .. no longer in service


#114 of 115 by keesan on Tue Aug 31 01:03:39 2010:

You can dial in free using VOIP.


#115 of 115 by kentn on Tue Aug 31 04:11:26 2010:

And on the one remaining Grex modem line...


There are no more items selected.

You have several choices: