No Next Item No Next Conference Can't Favor Can't Forget Item List Conference Home Entrance    Help
View Responses


Grex Synthesis Item 7: Coming of Age for a Young Man...suggestions invited
Entered by mta on Mon May 24 04:27:13 UTC 1993:

My eldest child will turn 13 this autumn, and the signs all say that he
is ready for his coming of age ceremony.

Problem:  I'm a single (female) parent.  I can address the child->adult
issues pretty well, but where it comes to boy->man issues I can only
imagine...

A friend of the family has volunteered to help me with this, but he's
pretty new to the whole spirituality thing and doesn't have any more
clue than I do, though for different reasons.

...so, what I wanted to ask the men here in this conference: Imagine
that you (or your son) are/is about to come of age.  What symbols
or rituals would you consider meaningful and appropriate?

We plan at his ceremony to have two parts...Friday and Saturday are the
"challenge" or more private part of the ceremony. Then Sunday we will
invite all of his friends and the extended family to the public
acknowledgement part.  Suggestions for either part are welcome.

This ceremony will take palce in some public but secluded cabins in
a clearing in the woods.  We will rent both cabins for 2 nights.
Both cabins sleep 20.  We'll rent both mainly for the privacy.

58 responses total.



#1 of 58 by om on Thu May 27 02:57:07 1993:

Dear mta, I just sent you an e-mail about the cheat sheet and here is a new
and interesting topic which inspires me to respond. When I was still a Hindu
monk, myself and another monk went on a ten month spiritual pilgrimage across
the  the USA. We went with backpacks and sleeping bags, and we visited
monasteries' and spiritual communities of different religions. Most of the time
we slept ' wherever we were when night fell. and we begged our meals and
hitchhiked and  jumped freight trains all across the country.

One of the most amazing things that we realized as we went along was that the
pilgrimage had become a rite of passage. Though we were both in our mid-
twenties, and had been monks (initiated, ordained...) we still had not had a 
ritual experience that defined our being/becoming men.

Now, when I speak of ritual, or when anyone speaks of ritual, it doesn't merely
reflect an outward set of prescribed actions and symbols...it means that, but
more] more, it means that one's psyche is open to the mythopoetic way of
thinking/ feeling.

People live by laws, facts, events...and the soul lives through poetry and
feeling. That is why some rituals seem empty...when the poetry of the sym-
bols have been rendered inaccessible. 

Many new rituals emerge from the very syobols And actions of ordinary life
when only a few things are added...for men. one of those things is the 
atmosphere of non-competitiveness between the older males and the younger
one.  When we went to some of the most amazing monasteries, these wonderful
men enthusiastically encouraged us in what we were doing.  That "blessing" 
is something entirely beyond the scope of our ordinary experiences from age
one and on, because from birth we are in a subtle competition with our father,
and then we get the male authorities at school and in religion.

But when a stranger, and older man, takes time to bless us, we move into that
interior space that says, "Hey. This is something special. This is not an 
ordinary thing."

The bestowal of gifts COMES from the tradition of blessing...for in the
blessing, we are given s- sing we are given spiritual gifts, which the physical
gifts symbolize. So  whatever we are to be ordained to receive spiritually,
often a symbol of  that is given externally...and what we hold as talents, are
often the very  channel for receiving praise. It is onky competition which
turns our talents


#2 of 58 by om on Thu May 27 03:03:01 1993:

mta from jesse: Continued: ...into avenues of conquest.  Try for a full moon.


#3 of 58 by cwb on Thu May 27 17:03:24 1993:

     I have never gone through any formal coming-of-age ceremony or rite
myself, so I'm not technically qualified to advise you.  Like your friend,
I'm very new to the "spirituality thing" Also, my particular brand is a much
more individualistic sort then the average.  There is a value in solitude,
especially for a teenage boy who spends much of his life intricately linked
into social fabrics.  I remember when I was that age, I often felt a little
overwhelmed by all the social forces brought to bear on me, and I went and
found some places to hide.  They weren't all physical places, that was when
I discovered Tolkien.  I still haven't lost my love for the master.
     I guess what I'm saying is that there's a value in chosen solitude that
you might take into consideration.  Hope this helps.
     Chris


#4 of 58 by mta on Thu May 27 21:08:27 1993:

Chris--(and everyone)

having been through a formal coming of age ceremony may even handicap you
in giving me the sorts of things I'm asking for.

I've never been through a formal coming of age ceremony, either--but I would
have little trouble helping to design one for a young girl...because I am
a woman and I know what it is to be a woman and how that
differes from being a girl.

Actually Chris, your talk about solitude was *exactly* the sort of input I
was looking for..


#5 of 58 by cwb on Fri May 28 18:59:25 1993:

     Well then, with that encouragement, I'll go on a little farther into
the realms of the obvious.  It seems to me that the ceremony needs to be
tailored to the boy.  For some, an intensively physical experience might be
appropriate, for other a contemplative one, and again for others, being set
some task of social value and then being told, go figure out how to do
this.  I don't know your son, so I'm not in a position to advise which of
these (if any) make sense, but the idea here might give you some places to
start.
     CB


#6 of 58 by md on Wed Jun 2 13:52:31 1993:

I'd be careful not to do anything that implies some sort of a 
dividing line, with childhood on one side and adulthood on the 
other.  If your son doesn't know yet he'll find out soon enough 
that there's no such line.  It's a fiction invented by grownups 
who've forgotten what it's like to be thirteen.  Kids know 
perfectly well that adults have this knack for turning the simplest 
most natural things into Big Deals.  

Experiences we think of as "adult" will come to your son when they 
will.  No coming of age ceremony can validate or hasten the 
process, nor should it.  And "leaving childish things behind" is 
not anything I'd encourage a teenager to do.  The best part of any 
adult is the part that hasn't changed since childhood.  If you 
banish it, or let it wither away, you might as well be dead.  
William Wordsworth said so: 

          My heart leaps up when I behold
            A Rainbow in the sky;
          So was it when my life began;
          So is it now I am a Man;
          So be it when I shall grow old,
            Or let me die!
          The Child is Father of the Man;
          And I could wish my days to be
          Bound each to each by natural piety.

No "coming of age" dividing line, just the unremarkable 
*continuity* of days bound each to each by that childish thing -- 
call it "natural piety" -- that makes the hearts of a few lucky 
grownups still leap up whenever they see a rainbow.  

As to the "boy --> man" aspect of it, if you keep current with 
things you must realize how politically incorrect you risk being by 
saying to a boy, "This is what it means to be a Man."  You'd have 
to be so careful what you said after that, that you might end up 
saying nothing at all, or else generic stuff that applies just as 
well to "girl --> woman".  Unless you *want* to do a Robert Bly or 
Tim Allen number on him, in which case who am I to judge?  ;-)

Finally, are you sure your son really wants something like this?  
I hate to bring this up, but kids generally find this sort of thing 
just excruciating.  But I want to think that your plans indicate 
either that your son is as enthusiastic about your spiritual ideas 
as you are, or else that you're able to put something together that 
will be fun for him.  In any case, best wishes from a fellow 
parent.


#7 of 58 by mta on Wed Jun 2 15:52:16 1993:

Actually, md, this planning comes after 3 years of him pestering for just such
a rite.  

Your comments on no solid line of demarcation are well made points, and I
think some acknowledgement of the things you bring up will have to be
a fundamental part of the message on his day.

On the other hand, there does come a time when it's proper to turn your
sights to what you wish to do with your time on earth--who you wish to
be.  These trhings are not for children--but as adulthood looms, it's
important to remind ourselves that growth becomes more of an effort in
adulthood than it was in childhood--but its equally necessary.

PC be damned!  I've raised my kids to believe that gender is irrelevant
until puberty--am I now to tell them that it doesn't mean anything after,
either??  ;)

There are certain things that being female/male do mean--whether they are
PC or not.  Unfortunatly my female experience has only made obvious what
being a man means missing out on.  That's not the legacy I want to give
my sons.  OK, they'll never experience the magick of menarche, nor of
pregnancy or birth, or nursing their child.  So, what is it to be a man.
It's (I hope) not Monday night football, or strip clubs with the guys--
my Dad's definition might come close to that.  


#8 of 58 by om on Sun Jun 6 17:29:19 1993:

mta...I've seen your responses to the other entries. does it not behove you rto
respond to me to respond to me? >


#9 of 58 by robh on Sun Jun 6 20:39:02 1993:

Misti, I've been giving this a lot of thought since you first entered
this item, and ya know what?  I still can't think of anything especially
masculine to be celebrated with a ritual.  Kind of pathetic, really.
The best I can come up with is competitiveness, overcoming obstacles
and the like - how athletically inclined is your son?  Or maybe a
Native American-style vision quest would be good.  A friend of mine went
on one last weekend, and she really enjoyed it.


#10 of 58 by mta on Mon Jun 7 01:17:55 1993:

Jesse, I'm sorry you feel that I've neglected your response.  Actually I've
read it several times.  I will definitely arrange for the rite to happen
at the full moon.  As to the rest...well I simply haven't come up with
a concrete way of understanding how to translate your experience for
a 13 year old.  We will give him meaningful gifts, of course--but I have
the sense that you meant something *far* more than that and I don't
understand what.  As I said in private mail, I'd appreciate it if you cared
to make your point in simpler, more concrete terms...but it seems presumptious
to ask that.

Rob, I just can't believe there aren't positive things about manhood.  I
know and love many men!  Our society may have turned those things to
striving at the expence of full personhood...but the bascis are there.
They have to be.  TJ is very strong, energetic, and in some ways he
is competative.  He doesn't show much interest in sports, though--so he
isn't an athlete in the usual sense.  

I am getting some ideas from this discussion of some elemnts that
should be included.  Thanks to all!


#11 of 58 by phaedrus on Mon Jun 7 01:37:29 1993:

I understand your feelings about the masculine Rob, I have been searching
for years to underd the masculine. In my life, (of only 24 years),
I can think of few men that have inspired me, but many women! 
Praise the Godess for those women, they have taught me more about being 
a man than men! But as women (and men) are revitalizing the Godess
archetypes, men, we, must do the same. It's not aeasy thing I agree, 
but unless we do it, it's not going to happen. Most of the Men's 
circles that I have attended are little more than testosterone ranting
sessions, I think those of us that are concerned must stand up, and
begin to reclaim the aspect of Man that we can be proud of, and pass
that on in rites of passage!
It's not an easy task, but then niether is going through life with 
, as the genetic symbol of abuse!
\
-Sorry about the soapboxing, but it pisses me off beyond words, to think of
what my Ansestoral "fathers" have done to the image of man. I understand
why men are hated, but I hate being hated simply because I am a man!
IO PAN, Praise Kerunos, ail Chango, CABIO SILE!!!
-Phaedrus


#12 of 58 by robh on Mon Jun 7 02:32:17 1993:

Or as Sylvester Stallone might invoke, "Yo, Pan!"

Phaedrus, I agree 100% on women providing more inspiration than men
in my life.  Glancing over at my CD collection from here, I see
WAAAAAY more albums by women (Kate Bush, Laurie Anderson, Tori Amos,
Suzanne Vega, Enya) than men, and I get a lot of my ideas and such
from music.

If there's any "masculine" concept I consider important to myself,
it's competition, be it gaming, fencing with my shinai, whatever.
It's the Klingon in me, I suppose.


#13 of 58 by phaedrus on Mon Jun 7 13:53:15 1993:

It sounds like you've a healthy view of competition, most men see it as
a way to have power over another, not a way for both people to grow.
I understand the "hunter" aspect, it's strong in me too.
Have you ever listened to Spirit of the west, or the Crash test dummies,
a couple of good bands with cool men!
Phaedrus


#14 of 58 by md on Mon Jun 7 16:05:03 1993:

There are lots of more or less healthy things that are 
traditionally considered to be "masculine".  Fathers playing catch 
or shooting baskets with their sons, fathers teaching their sons to 
fish, fathers getting their sons started in mechanics and in 
building and repairing things (insert Tim Allen growl here).  

I say these things are healthy, and they are.  What isn't healthy 
is the tradition that considers them to be "masculine".  Most 
people, even here in the conservative suburbs, are abandoning that 
tradition.  Daughters are included now in all of the above, or at 
least not excluded if they want to join in.  

If you allow any degree of artificiality in your son's coming of 
age ceremony, you could include references to some of these 
traditionally masculine things.  Religious rituals like to do that.  
Christian priests and ministers from many denominations still dress 
like upper-class Romans from 200 AD.  It's valuable because it 
gives a sense of continuity and stability, even if it doesn't 
really mean anything anymore.  ("Romanitas" hasn't been a prized 
quality for at least a millenium.)  

I can see the day when, for example, building and repairing things 
are things which both men and women in equal numbers do all the 
time in real life, but which are included only in boys' coming of 
age ceremonies, in aknowledgment of the generations of men who took 
these responsibilities on themselves in the past.


Not to sound too horribly PC, but maybe a formal abandoning of some
of the not-so-healthy "masculine" things from the past would also
be in order.


#15 of 58 by danr on Tue Jun 8 01:30:57 1993:

There's no reason that this coming of age has to be couched in
masculine terms.  Instead of becoming a "man," this could be a
becoming an adult kind of thing.  Not so much the giving up the
things of childhood, but the beginning of looking at things in an
adult way and becoming responsible for oneself.


#16 of 58 by mta on Tue Jun 8 03:07:35 1993:

Dan,  no I don't suppose it *has* to be couched in terms of the masculine,
but my son has to some extent grown up without a father.  I want to find
ways to help him to value that which is masculine in him.  I've met
so many men who say they wish they had been born female--not because
they are transexuals or anything, but because everything they value 
is manifest in what we as a society call female.  I think the women's 
movement has been a very good thing in making "female" qualities more
respected...but it does no more good for a young boy to think that
being female is superior than it did his mother to think that all that
is masculine is superior.  With a strong male presense in his home, he
might not have had questions about the value of masculinity...(I don't
know that he does now, for that matter) but I want to feed his esteem
for positive male qualities.  I'm convinced that only by loving what
we are can we truly value "other".

Anyway, competition, strength, self sufficiency...to some extent they are
human qualities, but they are primarily conceived of as male here and now.



#17 of 58 by om on Sat Jun 12 14:27:25 1993:

From Jesse: I am really glad to see all the activity on this conference. I am
not sure how to add to it, because 1 not sure how to add to it because 1) my
thoughts on this subject are related to intensely personal experiences and are
hard for most people to really  appe appreciate; 2) I don't have the usual bias
against male institutions, though I am critical  am critical, in a sense, I
feel that my manhood is no longer threatened by the patriarchy.

One direct answer to the original question is that your ritual will be con-
ditioned directly by your personal conception of what is spiritual.  If your
spiritual conception is not going to inform your ritual expression, then
what you are going to get is a ritual of social, and not spiritual form.

I am positive that a psychological event like this rite of passage, both
the spiritual and the social aspects are essential. Therefore, in order to 
"come into" one's spiritual and social responsibilities is and has been the 
principal content of such rituals, and this simply means that 1) you are 
suddenly awakened to the fact that you participate in the Cosmic Power (God);
2) that you are suddenly awakened to the fact that you participate singularly
(uniquely) in the organism of humanity.

I am sure that whatever ritual evolves out of your sincere desire to serve yy
your son will be an intimate flowering of your love for each other.


#18 of 58 by mta on Sat Jun 12 23:06:50 1993:

Jesse,  you may be the very person I want to talk to about how you see
masculinity.  After all, you are comfortable in it.  Please don't feel
that your contributions aren't welcome...as we get to know you better
your "intensely personal" experiences and insights will have a context
for us and we'll be quicker on the uptake.

You're right about keeping the spiritual content personal...and about the
fact that, in the end, the rite will be a product of our families love
for one another.


#19 of 58 by om on Sat Jun 19 03:35:28 1993:

Dear mta, for me, any meaningful (practical) definition of manhood has to 
relate to our cultural associations which have preceeded our birth. Why?
because to uncover the uniqueness of our own personal "expression" of the 
male sprit means in a large part to "deal with" the cultural associations
which are almost subconscious within our selves. I noticed that much of the 
conference so far has been a discussion of stereotypes...

It has been a picking and choosing. A accepting/rejecting process, and this
dialogue represents accurately the contemporary search. But what about the
findings? (I am being didactic. I don't mean to offend any others here.)

What are the "positive" findings? Where are the "answers? 

When I reconcile myself to the subconscious imperatives of our American 
cultural associations with manhood as a focus, I find that there is a lot
of adventure in our tradition. Is that a debatable quality? No. 

The archetypes of manhood in America also stand for idealism, objectivity and 
fairness, and risking everything for truth. I believe that these archetypes
also inform the subconscious of women, too. 

In our cultural context of course, we refer to the New World, the Frontier,
(in effect, the same mythos that guided the Hebrews: A Promised Land; and 
later, the Christians: The Kingdom of God. Essentially, we are guided by an
ancient evolution of symbols and ideas...even though we express them and think
about them quite differently than our ancestors did.

For me, the most significant process of my rite of passage (at 25), was to 
"draw down the myth", so to speak. ( I might add that the period of rejecting
assumptions of masculinity took me from 15 to 25.) So it took a long
soul-search to draw the myth down.

Down.

Into the flesh, where, finally I began to live the myths. I 

Like md was  saying previously, when the man has the adventure of the child,
he experiences the ultimate continuity. To the child, when he experiences the
commitment of the adult, he feels like the man. 

But how to give that experience to a 13 year old?  Do we just give him the keys
to a car or a bank account and say, "here, son. Use this power?" What about
setting him up for a let-down, due to his lack of experience! Do we say, "Here
is a tent. Go to the mountain?" Well, probably he'll get pretty bored when it
datr starts raining for two days.

Do we ultimately disclose to him, "hey kid, there is NO ceremony which will
transform you instantly, no pill to take...and besides, it's all a question
of paradoxes and dualities and you may need 10 years to figure it out?"

He's going to wonder where the magic is in that.

I bellieve that one of the most concrete things you can do for him is to 
help him evaluate his own perception of his "magic"; and to bring him into
contact with older men who can help him to become wise. He may need, as I did,
to spend time with men whom I could love and admire...spiritual fathers.

A note abour wisdom. It is the last archetype I can mention now.  It is not
directly an American cultural archetype. It is European, Eastern andMid-Eastern
as well as indiginous to many other races and cultures. But you never hear of 
wisdom mentioned in American men past Ben Franklin or Jefferson. Somewhere we
lost the Wise Old Man. So you will have to find him in another tradition, if
your going to bring your son toward him.

I believe, at this point, there are several spiritual options. You will find
wisdom where east meets west. Find an old master for him in whatever field he
is open to: old sportsmen are there in every town. Old painters are not hard
to find. Old journalists are wonderful. The main criteria for you to judge them
is a simple question: do you admire them? If so, you have your possible
mentor for your son. If he is truly admirable as a man, don't you think yourr
son will "feel" it? I think he will.

Thank you for giving me the opportunity to share my thoughts and ideas with
you. Jesse.


#20 of 58 by mta on Sat Jun 19 07:29:47 1993:

Jesse, the idea of finding a mentor to bring my son toward is a beautiful
one.  I love the idea of giving him to the Wise Old Man...or giving the WOM
to him.  (as if it matters who is given and who recieves)

I think TJ is mostt likely to find his mentor in fiction, where true
goodness and wisdom can be complete and unmarred.  He's quite an
idealist, and given to execting people to *earn* his respect.  Few can.
(One of his youthful conceits is that he is one to judge his elders.)

I think, perhaps, i am getting a clearer idea of what you were geting
at in your first post.  

As to finding him a mentor--well, as a single mom I've spent alot of
his life looking for male role models to expose him to--so maybe the time
has come to officially hand him the power to choose his own role models.

Very inspirational, this idea of seeking the adventure in maleness...hmmm.


#21 of 58 by om on Sun Jun 20 03:04:31 1993:

dear mta: Thank you for your kind and encouraging response. Last night I wa
wanted to say so much...I relish these topics so much. 

One thing that I didn't mention last night is a relization I had about my own
mentor search. You see, I quit school at 14. I was free from that system, and 
so I had all the time in the world to meet my mentors. My mother is a very ad-
venturous woman, and she had me auditing college classes instead of just 
just letting me drop out of all educational spheres completely. In this 
"adult" environment I met my first teacher, a hippy artist who was wanderiing 
through the campus.

Now granted, he was NOT a developed man. He was incredibly immature, and prone
to all kinds of vices...but he taught me how to illustrate comic books, and
set me on an alternative path in the arts.

talk shadow@grex.cyberspace.org
who what when where?


#22 of 58 by om on Sun Jun 20 03:14:16 1993:

Dear mta...sorry for the interruption, I got this talk message that I was
trying to figure out.

Anyways. The point of what I was relating was that the first mentor was not
wise. but in the beginning, I thought he was wise ssimply because he was 
alternative. I think that regarding your feeling of turning over the power
to TJ to choose his mentors, he will choose first according to his capacity
to percieve their "wisdom". 

As it turned out, I had literally scores of mentors who guided me over the 
next ten years...and gradually, as they led me into new experiences, and 
I applied all I knew, I met more and more quality mentors. 


#23 of 58 by mta on Mon Jun 21 03:41:42 1993:

Jesse, I think I know what you're saying...

I don't consider handing TJ the power to choose his own mentors to be any
excuse to stop putting good men in his path when I can.  It's more like
acknowledging that they can't teach him until chooses to learn from them.


#24 of 58 by phaedrus on Tue Jun 22 15:30:55 1993:

If the student thinks the teacher is great, the teacher will be great!!
Not allways true, but in good circumstances it holds true.
-Phaedrus


#25 of 58 by om on Wed Jun 23 02:51:17 1993:

Hi. I agree with you about continuing to put good men in his reach. I was
merely concerned to clarify the experience that I had of a long process of
discipleship which, though starting out with mediocre teachers, nevertheless
proceeded to greater and greater ones. I know that this was a difficult and 
long wait for my own mother; who had to see many of my worst chioces come 
first. And, actually, it was only the last few that she loved with me. 


#26 of 58 by jones2 on Sun Aug 22 23:52:43 1993:

Man is strong, safe, and kind. His love energizes, inspires, and nurtures.
Man's love for his children and his god[s] is sublime and infinite.
So often has Man's bared and brave breast stood off the aggressor.
Man's tears are shed less than his blood lest those that seek his strength
see and become afraid. This Man makes no apology and I offer no protest.


#27 of 58 by phaedrus on Mon Aug 23 14:18:51 1993:

Chris,
you have given an ideal list of what being a man should mean. (except for
the blood more than tears maybe!)
To me this seems rather unreal, if you emulate this desciption, God and
Godess bless, but realize to many peoples experience you are a minority.
Unless you were born into a "Leave it to Beaver" world, you must see that
the image of man has been twisted for many years now. And we, all men,
must work to change this perception, by trying to shed more tears and less
blood!! This is not to say, we must sit down and cry all the time, but 
don't be afraid of it. I dare say that more people are afraid of one who
would rather shed blood than a tear!!??
The cutting comments about man, are not pointed at the man that you speak of,
but the man that many of us have grown to know, or not to know. So take no
offense at the comments, unless you are one of these, creatures, who dare
take the name, Man, and do so little to do it, and us, honor.
-phaedrus
working to bring honor to men AND women.


#28 of 58 by jones2 on Mon Sep 27 00:18:31 1993:

This response has been erased.



#29 of 58 by robh on Mon Sep 27 02:28:26 1993:

And your response is writ in /bbs/censored, jones2.  Why do you
jab at others and then attempt to hide it?  Please, either stand up
for what you believe in and leave it for all to see, or keep it
to yourself.


#30 of 58 by phaedrus on Mon Sep 27 12:52:39 1993:

Huh...?? What's up?
Did I miss something Rob?
I hate being the only one to miss a joke.
-phaedrus


#31 of 58 by phaedrus on Mon Sep 27 16:40:26 1993:

Found it! Thanks for the mao Rob.
                         map
Chris,...uh...I'd like to understand what your doing, but I don't. Please
explain. What have I said that you think is "drivel"??
Or have you just dropped to name calling. That's ok, you are giving me
and all that see your post a wonderful example of what being a "man"
has become. Fortunatly some of us are working to find out what it really
means to be a man.
Peace and blessings,
-phaedrus


#32 of 58 by jones2 on Mon Sep 27 22:48:39 1993:

Frankly boys, your politically correct groupthink is riddled with the cliches
of the future. As I read, I am occasionally piqued. I then respond honestly
if discourteously. This is my shame. It follows then that I immediately
regret my injurious comments and attempt to retract them. In a sense it pleases
me that you can retreive them as it was only an attempt to spare your tender
feelings that compelled my censorship. Enjoy your play Fey. You may rest
assured that one day you will discover the true nature of man.[If not in this
go round then in some other]. How is it that I should come out to here and be
still floating? ...and never hit bottom but keep falling through just relaxed
and paying ATTENTION. GODDESS BLESS and keep you. WHAT DOES WOMAN WANT? where
are you now? Don't just answer....LOOK! wq


#33 of 58 by jones2 on Mon Sep 27 22:59:45 1993:

Incidently Rob, You have my permission to restore whatever I have scribbled
I don't know how. I truly was attempting to leave your gang its own tur
free from territorial fears when I scribbled and also when I expurgurated.


#34 of 58 by phaedrus on Tue Sep 28 01:30:05 1993:

Thanks for reponding Chris. I can see that you thought that you were 
damaging the "group". I don't think you were. I'm just trying to get more
of an understanding of what you're saying. I'll take the stop look and
listen to heart. And I hope you're right about me finding the true 
nature of man, be it now or another life. 
As for advice to you, be confident of what you say, or don't say it. 
Discussions at this depth can become intense, and are normally very
emotional. These discussions are also where real learning taked place. 
                                                          takes
The reason what you said about man pissed me off is that too many men are
denying the problems that men have caused and blindly trod forward
making the same mistakes. And if we don't know our past...
I hope that you don't turn tail and run, (snicker snicker), but stay and
continue to challange me, and I'm sure others. 
"The wisest sage is the one who admits he is a fool..."
I'm all ears...ok not quite but sorta
-phaedrus


#35 of 58 by robh on Tue Sep 28 02:21:53 1993:

Chris, don't feel you have to spare me from foreign thoughts.  Yesterday
I read an open letter from a man trying to convince me I was really a
Satanist and that magic didn't work anyway.  Compared to that, your
responses have been downright pleasant.  I'm not afraid of
criticism, just disappointed by what looked like cowardice.  (And no,
there's no way for me to un-scribble something, not that I know of anyway.)

On the other hand, if you really think we're all an incestuous bunch
of politically correct (ptui!) morons, why stay at all?  Turn and walk
away.  "To oppose something is to maintain it."  (Darn it, I
can't remember if it was Lao-Tze or Schuang-Tze who said that!)

And if you're trying to rile me or phaedrus, don't bother.  You're
a long way away from me, through a narrow grey wire, and your hatred
hurts nobody but yourself.


#36 of 58 by jones2 on Tue Sep 28 10:11:32 1993:

A fool who encounters wisdom learns as much as the soup learns from the 
spoon.----Darn, I can't remember who said that.


#37 of 58 by phaedrus on Tue Sep 28 12:39:24 1993:

"Oh, I'm not a slave to f...WHAT'S THE DIFFERENCE, NOW YOU'RE A SLAVE
TO WHAT'S NOT FASION..." Rev. Ivan Stang
-phaedrus


#38 of 58 by cwb on Fri Nov 19 20:14:01 1993:

     I realize that this is now out of date, but for future reference, all
responses that are expurgated are in fact saved in a file somewhere,
(there's info in the info conference on it.)  It therefore aught to be
possible to find the particular response, then simply copy it into a file
and finally port it back to the conference.
     Enjoy.


#39 of 58 by foxx on Sun Feb 20 16:29:22 1994:

Now that the flamewars have died down a bit :-), is there anybody out there
that would like to continue this topic?  Here's some of my thoughts...

In most tribal cultures (if not all) the transition from child to adult is
not as traumatic as it is in ours.  We tend to send very confusing messages
to children as to their roles and responsibilities.  Children growing up
in tribal societies are not expected to act "grown up" and are free to be
relatively innocent of adult style responsibility.  They observe the 
behavior of their elders and come to understand what a man and a woman are
by example, but they are protected from adult expectations by the fact that
they are not to start assuming these roles until their "coming out" ceremony.
They may play or practise thier future roles but this is carried out among 
the children and they don't try to play these roles with adults before thier
time has come.  During the period of transition (usually the length of the
vigal) they are taught (more like reminded, since they mostly already know)
what is expected of them as adults.  Then IMMEDIATELY following the end of the
ceremony they are adults.  Their roles and responsiblities instantly change
and their new status is reinforced and encouraged by the society.  The 
confusion is minimal and the result is a fairly well adjusted adult who can
fully function as such (athough experience is needed beyond this point).

     By contrast, in our society we have lost the transitional ceremony.  We
start sending signals to our children at quite a young age that they should 
act more grown up, big boys don't cry, act like a man, etc.  We have stretched
the transitional period out to many years.  During this period the child is 
torn between these two phases of life.  If they try out some adult behaviors
around adults at too early an age they are slapped back by older children and 
adults.  We end up with people going through their lives in all sorts of 
different states of maturity, leading to teenage angst, mid-life crisis' etc.
As I'm sure you all know, getting to the point that you are fully accepted as
an adult, by the people around you and yourself, is quite painful and confusing

So given all of that, and the fact that we can't just instantly change our soc
society, how do we come up with an effective remedy for our children to help
them through this transition? You could create an effective system within 
your own family where adulthood and childhood are clearly defined and put
your child through the transitional ceremony.  BUT, will the childs new 
status be accepted and reinforced by it's peers and other adults?? It dosn't
seem likely.
     Sorry this went on so long, just trying to get something started.
Fox


Last 19 Responses and Response Form.
No Next Item No Next Conference Can't Favor Can't Forget Item List Conference Home Entrance    Help

- Backtalk version 1.3.30 - Copyright 1996-2006, Jan Wolter and Steve Weiss