No Next Item No Next Conference Can't Favor Can't Forget Item List Conference Home Entrance    Help
View Responses


Grex Language Item 10: First words
Entered by jennie on Wed Sep 4 00:35:51 UTC 1991:

What was your first word when you were a baby?

Griz

44 responses total.



#1 of 44 by polygon on Wed Sep 4 03:09:54 1991:

"Button."


#2 of 44 by jennie on Wed Sep 4 06:25:28 1991:

"Ba" (meaning "bottle").  I loved to eat even then....

Griz


#3 of 44 by arabella on Sat Nov 30 17:49:43 1991:

I'm not sure what my first word was, but my sister's first word
(she's 2 and a half years younger than I) was "lelie", baby
talk for Leslie.  I imagine my mother was chagrined.


#4 of 44 by griz on Sat Nov 30 21:08:04 1991:

Oh, that's wonderful!  I like that.


#5 of 44 by reach on Tue Dec 3 14:39:43 1991:

"Quiet"
(some careers are ordained, apparently)


#6 of 44 by tcc on Wed Dec 4 09:24:33 1991:

"Shit"



#7 of 44 by reach on Sat Dec 7 06:13:59 1991:

As I said.


#8 of 44 by reach on Sat Dec 7 06:14:34 1991:

(that was most certainly meant as a joke, Mr. tcc, and not a flame of
any variety)


#9 of 44 by mdw on Wed Dec 11 13:30:00 1991:

"Light".  Apparently, I didn't appreciate being put in the dark
every night.


#10 of 44 by jdg on Fri Dec 13 04:12:57 1991:

Gee, Marcus, wasn't "More light" someone's famous *last* words?


#11 of 44 by reach on Fri Dec 13 06:56:19 1991:

"Bud Light".


#12 of 44 by mdw on Sat Dec 14 06:46:43 1991:

You know what they say, great minds think alike.  :-)


#13 of 44 by tcc on Sat Dec 14 06:55:37 1991:

Heh, I only take responses from tnt as a flame, be at rest.



#14 of 44 by craig on Sat Jan 18 20:53:20 1992:

"Kick out the Jams, Brothers and Sisters!"


#15 of 44 by mta on Sat Feb 15 20:24:08 1992:

Cigarette.  My uncle spent the better part of a weekend visit trying
to get me to say that--boy, was Mom pissed when I did!


#16 of 44 by popcorn on Sun Feb 16 09:57:34 1992:

This response has been erased.



#17 of 44 by tsty on Mon Jun 1 21:02:45 1992:

but wait a minute, popcorn, it was the MOST original thing you
ever said (redundancy aside, please).
  


#18 of 44 by remmers on Tue Jun 2 06:34:42 1992:

My first word was "Norflin".


#19 of 44 by reach on Fri Jun 19 14:02:30 1992:

Mine, too.


#20 of 44 by aa8ij on Fri Aug 28 06:29:11 1992:

 I think my first word was " Mine!!!!" 


#21 of 44 by tsty on Fri Aug 28 18:27:30 1992:

  <<sibling rivalry for breast milk?>>


#22 of 44 by robh on Sat Aug 29 04:52:57 1992:

One of my friends' first word was "book", and her son's first word
was "thirteen", or "firteen" as he put it.


#23 of 44 by davel on Tue Sep 1 21:40:26 1992:

A friend relates that her first word was "big truck" (spoken from a car).


#24 of 44 by remmers on Tue Sep 1 22:59:06 1992:

No, her first word was "big" and her second was "truck".  :)


#25 of 44 by davel on Thu Sep 3 01:23:53 1992:

I plead guilty - I suspect that she said "my first words were ...", but I
don't remember.  We were talking around 3 years ago...


#26 of 44 by grundy on Sun Sep 6 14:16:46 1992:

indigo has been saying 'ca'
i believe she is trying to say 'cat'
since she gets very excited
every time she sees one
and says 'ca!' over and over.
does this count as a first word
even if she is missing the 't'?


#27 of 44 by mta on Sun Sep 6 17:37:50 1992:


It does indeed! 


#28 of 44 by davel on Mon Sep 7 02:24:59 1992:

I believe Jonathan's first word was also "cat" pronounced "ca" (short "a").
Somewhat later this caused him confusion with "car" pronounced similarly.

In other words, I second mta.

(Otherwise, many or most children would be in the anomalous position of
talking for weeks or months before they said their first words!  Even now,
at 2, Paul has only a few complete, clear, correct words.  Peanut butter
is "ahmbur" (for almond butter, which was originally preferred).)


#29 of 44 by mta on Mon Sep 7 18:27:06 1992:

My rule of thumb is that if *the child* knows what <s>he means, and you can 
guess...then it's a real attempt at communication.  ie. a word.


#30 of 44 by davel on Mon Sep 7 19:21:46 1992:

... hmm ...
What do you mean, "mean"?  In a case like this?  (I'm not denying, only
questioning.)  If you look at a lot of recent work (my real acquaintance
being 15 years ago) in epistemology & philosophy of language, you find
some people seriously questioning whether statements like "The dog knows its
master is on the other side of the door" (or substitute "thinks" for "knows")
can ever be true, because thinking requires concepts which requires language.
(That's rough - sorry.)  I think that the same arguments would apply equally
well (or equally badly) to pre-linguistic children.

Mind you, I always kind of thought these people were wrong ... but I never
got my hands dirty at the level of detail necessary to say I could prove it.

On recalling some more, I think I oversimplified the position I describe a
bit too much to be fair.  Let me try again: knowledge & belief *that*
something (not "knowing how") require something like a proposition as the
object of belief.  For propositions to have content of a sort that can be
expressed in language requires something like a language on the part of the
subject.  I think that at issue would be (partly) whether we could pick out
THIS proposition as the content of the belief as opposed to a myriad of other
significantly-different propositions.

I think I'm still not being fair - a sign that I disagree and that my weed-
grown memory isn't cooperating.  The whole line of argument requires drawing
a line between conceptual equivalence between different languages & concep-
tual equivalence between language & non-linguistic-but-simple concepts.
Sigh.  If anyone finds my rambling interesting or even comprehensible I could
probably dig up a couple of references in the literature.  (Or more likely
someone else can jump in & clear me up - Jennie, don't sociolinguists haave
to study this stuff too?)

What I think I should have said is:  You're right, but there are complicated
& important issues lurking just under the surface.  (And you *did* say this
was a rule of thumb.)
p


#31 of 44 by tsty on Mon Oct 26 06:51:12 1992:

Iwas told that my "first word" was ma-ma, which shortly became "wa-wa"
for water, and taht was only because I couldn't say "beer."


#32 of 44 by orinoco on Tue Aug 25 21:07:40 1998:

My first word was "duuh!", apparently meaning "duck!"


#33 of 44 by coyote on Wed Aug 26 02:07:24 1998:

Mine was "clock"


#34 of 44 by albaugh on Wed Aug 26 16:27:19 1998:

Jeez, 6 years between responses, that must be a record!  :-)


#35 of 44 by kami on Thu Aug 27 03:34:20 1998:

Let's see- I think Timothy's was bird.  Gareth's was an attempt at "thank
you".


#36 of 44 by coyote on Thu Aug 27 05:25:17 1998:

(Hmmm... then "clock" seems to be a really appropriate first word after a
6-year time lapse in the conversation!)


#37 of 44 by gracel on Thu Aug 27 16:47:38 1998:

Comment on #28 -- Jonathan's first word was not just "cat" but "kitty-cat",
pronounced more like "ki'y-ca'".


#38 of 44 by orinoco on Thu Aug 27 21:14:29 1998:

That's impressive.


#39 of 44 by gracel on Sat Aug 29 13:40:23 1998:

There were three very important parties in his everyday life at the time:
Mommy, Daddy, and the kitty-cat.  After impressing us with "ki'y-ca", he then 
spent weeks on his version of "Daddy".  My theory was that he didn't need
to talk *about* me because I was usually there.


Last 5 Responses and Response Form.
No Next Item No Next Conference Can't Favor Can't Forget Item List Conference Home Entrance    Help

- Backtalk version 1.3.30 - Copyright 1996-2006, Jan Wolter and Steve Weiss