No Next Item No Next Conference Can't Favor Can't Forget Item List Conference Home Entrance    Help
View Responses


Grex Classicalmusic Item 21: "Romantic" music
Entered by md on Sun Dec 28 14:02:10 UTC 1997:

"Romantic" in quotes because I don't mean Romantic as in late Schubert
through early Mahler, I mean "romantic" as in snuggling by the fireplace
with your sweetheart.

Rachmaninov's slow movements are the gold standard, I guess.  The 3rd
movement of his 2nd symphony, the 18th variation from his Paganini
Rhapsody, and so on.  What turns you on?

10 responses total.



#1 of 10 by mary on Sun Dec 28 14:43:00 1997:

I tend to hear instruments as voices so an orchestra is a choir, a chamber
ensemble is a group of friends, and a solo instrument is one-on-one
conversation.  Maybe this is why I tend to think of the most romantic
music as simple (as in non-complex) music played in an intimate setting by
either a piano or a cello (base voices). 

The one piece that immediately comes to mind is Mendelssohn's Songs
Without Words, Op.19, No.1.  I don't think I've ever heard John play it
where the routine of life didn't stop for a few while the music summarized
lots of feelings.  It is an elegantly beautiful piece of music. 



#2 of 10 by teflon on Sun Jan 4 14:25:00 1998:

Yeah, that's a nice one.  I think for me it would have to be "vocalise" by
(I think) Rochmanin.  It's such a lovely peice that it just makes me stop
whatever I'm doing and relax a bit, whenever I hear it.


#3 of 10 by md on Sun Jan 4 16:22:54 1998:

The composer is Rachmaninov.  Yes, "Vocalise" is exceptionally
beautiful in that way.  Rachmaninov had a serious knack for that.


#4 of 10 by teflon on Sun Jan 4 22:56:36 1998:

I know how to spell it.  The only reason that I misspelled his name is because
my brain moves faster than my fingers, it all. <Snif>


#5 of 10 by md on Mon Jan 5 00:10:17 1998:

Wait'll you get to my age and your fingers move faster than
your brain.


#6 of 10 by orinoco on Mon Jan 5 03:35:34 1998:

Myself, I find that music intended to sound romantic is too sappy for my
tastes.  The music I find romantic tends to be dissonantly beautiful -
heartache and love all in one, I guess.  So, Stravinsky's less violent pieces,
such as the slower movements from _Rite of Spring_, are the example that
springs to mind - pieces on the tail end of the Romantic period.  


#7 of 10 by srw on Thu Jan 8 01:27:30 1998:

I love those but don't find them particularly romantic.

I find the Bachianas Brazileiras #5 by Heitor Villa-Lobos
romantic, at least parts of it. I don't think it was intended to be, 
though. It's a favorite of mine, anyway.


#8 of 10 by srw on Thu Jan 8 01:29:21 1998:

(It's scored for a soprano and 8 cellos. That's part of it.)


#9 of 10 by faile on Thu Jan 8 04:46:33 1998:

The second movement of Dvorak's New World Symphony gets me every time. 
There's just something about the simple melody in the English Horn and the
contrasts in teh strings... oooh.  


#10 of 10 by orinoco on Thu Feb 19 23:45:06 1998:

Ooh, yeah, Dvorak.  Good stuff, that.  Have you heard his Piano Quintet in
A Major?  Probably the best piece of chamber music I've ever heard..

Response not possible - You must register and login before posting.

No Next Item No Next Conference Can't Favor Can't Forget Item List Conference Home Entrance    Help

- Backtalk version 1.3.30 - Copyright 1996-2006, Jan Wolter and Steve Weiss