You are not logged in. Login Now
 0-24   25-49   50-74   75-83       
 
Author Message
25 new of 83 responses total.
aruba
response 25 of 83: Mark Unseen   Mar 28 03:29 UTC 1999

Can anyone explain why that is in terms a non-electrical engineer can
understand?
scott
response 26 of 83: Mark Unseen   Mar 28 12:41 UTC 1999

Heck, I don't really understand it myself.  Anyway, it is not an exact science
when applied to commercially available UPSs.
rcurl
response 27 of 83: Mark Unseen   Mar 28 17:29 UTC 1999

It is easy. Current only flows through a capacitor when it is charging or
discharging. Therefore when AC is applied across a capacitor the current
is maximum when the voltage is changing most rapidly, and the current is
zero when the voltage is maximum or minimum and not changing (at that
instant). The current is therefore one-quarter of a cycle out of phase
with the voltage (-90 degrees, phase lead). VA is the average product of
the voltage and current if they are *in phase*. W is the true average
product of voltage and current. Draw those two sine waves with the 90
degrees phase lag and multiply them together at each point. You will find
both positive and negative products which average out to zero. Hence, W =
0 while VA is large. (The capacitor won't even get hot except due to
secondary effects of resistance and dielectric losses). 

A similar explanation applies to inductors, except there the current lags
the voltage by 1/4 cycle (90 degrees).

The current through a capacitor when AC is applied is proportional to the
voltage and to the capacitance (and also to the frequency). Therefore the
capacitors acts somewhat like a resistor except for that frequency
dependence (with "resistance" inversely proportional to capacitance - it
is called "reactance" instead of resistance if that 90 degree phase shift
occurs). 

Somewhat more mysterious is what happens when a capacitor and inductor are
put in series. At a frequency where the reactances of the capacitor and
inductor are equal, the series reactance of the combination disappears and
there is neither reactance or resistance to current flow (unless there are
losses in the capacitor or DC resistance in the inductor). This leads to
the advanced course in which resonant circuits are treated....

aruba
response 28 of 83: Mark Unseen   Mar 28 23:35 UTC 1999

Ok, Rane, since you volunteered:  What's a capacitor?  What do you mean when 
you say "VA is the average product of the voltage and current if they are *in
phase*" - in phase how?  I understand that you're saying that current is
proportional to the derivative of voltage, so that if
        voltage = a*sin(wt)
for some constants a and w, then
        current = b*cos(wt)
for some constant b.  Then
        power = voltage * current = a*b*sin(wt)*cos(wt) = (ab/2)sin(2wt)
which indeed averages 0 over a long stretch of time.  But why is "VA"
different from power?
other
response 29 of 83: Mark Unseen   Mar 29 04:20 UTC 1999

a capacitor is a device which, when a charge is applied to it, stores 
that charge up to a certain limit, and which, when the charge is no 
longer applied, discharges until its overall charge is back to zero.

it is, for example, a common component in a circuit which converts AC to 
DC, because the bridge rectifier (made of four diodes in a certain 
configuration) only allows the flow of current in one direction.  This 
results in current only being available half of the time.  Imagine a 
sine wave with the bottom half cut off.  The capacitor will charge 
during the positive half of the cycle, somewhat reducing the available 
current, and discharge during the negative half, somewhat increasing the 
available current.

The last AC to DC converter I made took in a feed of about 117 VAC and 
put out about 90 VDC.
rcurl
response 30 of 83: Mark Unseen   Mar 29 06:43 UTC 1999

A capacitor consists of two conducting plates (or films) in close
proximity but not touching. When a voltage is applied an static electric
field is set up in the space between in which energy is stored. If you
remove the voltage source, the static field remains as does also the
voltage difference between the two plates. If a conductor is then put
between the two plates, the capacitor discharges as the field is drained.
This all occurs even if there is a vacuum between the plates. If some
material is put there, one not only gets better insulation between the
plates, but the atoms of the material participate in the field and
displacement of electrons and nuclei occur, which considerably increases
the capacitance.

If both the current and voltage are in phase, we can write v = Vsin(wt) 
and i = Asin(wt), where V and A are the maximum voltage and current
respectively. Power (work per unit time) is the product of voltage and
current at each instant. If i and v are in phase, this product is always
positive, and work is being done (whether in a motor, being converted to
mechanical work, or in a resistor, being converted to heat). If i and v
are out of phase less work is done, since i*v is alternatively positive
and negative, where if it is negative it means that the system (capacitor) 
is doing work hurrying those little electrons along. If we call the
leading phase shift between i and v p, v = Vsin(wt) but i = Isin(wt + p). 
So when p is not zero, the circuit is alternately absorbing energy and
releasing some of it back into the circuit, until when p = pi/2 (radians =
90 degrees), the absorbed and returned energy are identical and no work is
done. (Look upon the condition of the current flowing in the opposite
direction with voltage in the positive direction as the system being a
generator.) 

prp
response 31 of 83: Mark Unseen   Mar 29 06:57 UTC 1999

Capacitor: A device which tends to prevent voltage changes.
Inductor:  A device which tends to procent current changes.
 
Put them in a ciruct and Ohm's Law, V = A * R, goes out the
window.  This leads to the Power Factor, or how much energy
is actually being used vs. how much the utility is charging
for.
mdw
response 32 of 83: Mark Unseen   Mar 29 06:57 UTC 1999

Power = push x speed.  In electrical terms, push = voltage, & speed =
current.  For DC work, it suffices to measure v & i (current), & compute
the power directly.  With AC, however, the voltage is in fact constantly
varying; so what you really need to compute is the integral of the
product, v*i, computed across one complete cycle.  If the load is purely
resistive, i is directly proportional to the instantaneous v, & this is
easy.  A capacitive or inductive load moves the "i" curve so that it is
out of phase with the "v" curve.

A pure capacitor takes no current at constant voltage, and only eats
current if the voltage changes.  Basically, a capacitor "stores" a
charge.  An inductor "stores" current - it will "push" back (and
generate a back voltage), if something tries to push more current
through, or resist sending as much current through.  If you were to
compare electricity to water; voltage = water pressure, current = water
flow, a capacitor is a big rubber diaphram that can "store" water, and
an inductor is a big length of pipe with really smooth sides.  With
water, if you shut off a valve very quickly, the water that's flowing
through the pipe to the valve has momemtum in it, and will try to "kick"
at the valve (and generate a pressure spike) as it tries to keep flowing
- this is the water hammer effect.  This works with electricity as well
- the ignition coil in an automobile is basically a really long slick
pipe to the electricity, and when the contacts in the distributor open
(assuming your car is that old), the electricity that had been flowing
through the ignition coil generates a voltage spike, and jumps the gap
in the spark plug instead.

So, getting back to AC.  Suppose V is a sine wave.  At "0", the voltage
is rapidly increasing, so lots of current is flowing into the capacitor
to charge it.  But since V is near 0, there is almost now power.  At
pi/2, the voltage is at a max, but not changing much at all.  The
capacitor is fully charged with energy, but again, little power is
flowing.  At pi, the voltage is dropping rapidly, and lots of current is
flowing, but again, voltage is near 0, so there is little power involved
here.  At 3*pi/2, v is near -1, & i is near 0, and so the cycle goes.
Inbetween the quadrants, v & i are both non-zero, so power is in fact
happening, but half the time, this power is positive, & half negative.
Basically, the current is in advance of the voltage curve by 90 degrees,
and the power that is generated in 1/2 of the cycle is consumed in the
other half, so no real work is generated.  With an inductive load,
something similar happens except that the current lags behind the
voltage by 90 degrees.

If you combine an inductor and a capacitor, you can cancel out the two
effects, and end up with a purely resistive load instead (if the two are
"=", which in turn depends on the frequency and the relative values of
each).  In the water model above, that would be equivalent to putting
some sort of air filled chamber near the valve that's being shut off.
When the water gets turned of quickly, the water that's flowing will
compress the air in the chamber instead of trying to break the pipe.
This is sometimes done with washing machines, for instance.
rcurl
response 33 of 83: Mark Unseen   Mar 29 14:39 UTC 1999

Re #31: so a switch is an inductor, and a capacitor is a dead short?
keesan
response 34 of 83: Mark Unseen   Apr 1 00:59 UTC 1999

I just read the preceding 10 responses or so to Jim, pant, pant.
Who says "I am really concerned what my electrical meter thinks the difference
is between VA and W.    I don't think my electrical meter cares. If I ran
half-wave load off my electric meter I think it's still going to give me a
full reading of usage.  If they say there's a difference, what effect does
the difference have on the average Joe or Jane in the street or in the
kitchen?  For DC VA=W, for AC it averages out that way over the long run?
If it's not, I want to know what kind of load to put on my electrical meter
so that I can receive the most for my money.  Which appliances run more
efficiently - resistive, inductive, capacitive."  (What's a capacitive
appliance, Sindi asks.  Jim says 'a radio'.  Inductive appliance - motor. 
Resistive - stove.).
rcurl
response 35 of 83: Mark Unseen   Apr 1 07:56 UTC 1999

The power company doesn't like low power fractors any more than your
electric bill does. Appliances generally have power factor compensators
built in, except for startup of motors. 

I don't think radios are capacitive loads. They have transformers,
which present a partly inductive load. In any case, in all cases, W < VA,
but still not very different except under very light loads (when VA is
small anyway) or at startup, as I said. 
pfv
response 36 of 83: Mark Unseen   Apr 1 18:51 UTC 1999

        P= IE
        E= I^2 R

        Nuff' said.
rcurl
response 37 of 83: Mark Unseen   Apr 1 21:18 UTC 1999

But incorrectly said. P = IEp, where p is the power factor cos(u), where
u is the phase shift. E = IZ (I is not squared) and Z is the reactance,
not the resistance. 
pfv
response 38 of 83: Mark Unseen   Apr 2 13:27 UTC 1999

        <shrug> Not according to the texts and labs I had at WCC, but..
        "oh, well"..

rtg
response 39 of 83: Mark Unseen   Apr 6 17:53 UTC 1999

I remember a few years back, lots of discussion about 'power factor
controllers' which were supposed to lower your electric bills, by 'tuning'
the loads in your house to reduce the phase difference between current and
voltage.  I have not tried or tested them, since most discussions I heard
ended up with the statement that they are mostly hype, with little payback.

How does this really affect us?  We're not running big motors at the pumpkin,
so I'm guessing that we've got an aggregate power factor near unity, anyway.
How are we measuring our load currently?  Do we have access to a true RMS
wattmeter, or are we measuring AC current, and multiplying by AC voltage?  If
the latter, we have measured VA, not watts.
  To get back on topic:  Most UPSes have their capacity specified in both VA
and watts.  All we need to do is look at the number that corresponds to our
own system of measurement.  
mdw
response 40 of 83: Mark Unseen   Apr 13 06:05 UTC 1999

Your electric meter measures va*h, not w*h (despite its name of
"wattmeter").  If your power factor is way off, then essentially you get
less energy, or the energy you do get is way more expensive.  This is
the power company's way of encouraging you to have a more sane power
factor.

For grex, the difference is probably not that important.  When sizing a
UPS, you don't get a unit that is "exactly" big enough, you get a unit
that is significantly over-sized.  That way, adding an extra board, or
having components that age and change ratings, won't cause capacity
problems.
lilmo
response 41 of 83: Mark Unseen   Apr 14 00:38 UTC 1999

Re #39:  I'm not sure marcus would appreciate us doing too much measuring of
watts...  :-)

To repaeat my point of 30 messages ago, which was a summary of two even
earlier ones:  We need to figure our needs, first, and outline our wants, too,
 and see what brand/size meets those most economically (remembering that the
 degree of reliability and service goes into the wants/needs category, to be
 met before considering price).

Have we done this?
rtg
response 42 of 83: Mark Unseen   May 16 03:44 UTC 1999

Mebbe this should be posted in the 'random grexer sightings' item...

This afternoon, I observed a Grex board member finalizing a deal for a
1.5KVA Liebert UPS.  I'll let him post the details, But I'll say it was a
fantastic deal!
steve
response 43 of 83: Mark Unseen   May 18 03:32 UTC 1999

   Heh.

   I'll post the details tomorrow, when I'm more human.

   Saturday at the Dayton hamvention, I spottted a large, fat UPS for sale.

   It was a nice one.  A fat *heavy* 1.5KVA unit made by Liebert, *unused*.
It was being dumped because the unit had sat around for too long for its
batteries to be considered 'new', and wound up at the swap because of this.

   This is a monster unit, capable of supplying power at 1.5KVA for seven
minutes.  Probably we'll see a little less than that, but I'm not concerned
about that much.  SHould we ever want to extend the capacity of this we
could get a battery extender unit.

   I tried contacting a couple other board members when I first saw it, but
folks were out on the grex walk, I think.  After looking at it and talking
with Glenda, we got it.  Given the speed in which things sell a swap, had
we waiting to talk with others, it would have been gone by the time we made
a collective decision.

   We got it for $175.  Given that the UPS fund is currently at $119, the
fund is almost there now.

   My plan is to take it to the Pumpkin when Damon is around (this thing
is HEAVY) and we'll set it up and test it out.  Right now, all of Grex
could live off this monster.  I believe we're at 915w or so.

   This was a hell of a deal.  More on the model number etc tomorrow.
mary
response 44 of 83: Mark Unseen   May 18 10:19 UTC 1999

Will this unit run in the pumpkin without changes to our
electric service?
steve
response 45 of 83: Mark Unseen   May 18 11:26 UTC 1999

   No.  It will very likely lessen our electrical load.  The current power
conditioner we have is extremely inefficient in terms of power usage.
We'll measure it, but I very much doubt that we'll see anything in the
way of an increase in power usage.
remmers
response 46 of 83: Mark Unseen   May 18 20:34 UTC 1999

(You opened resp:45 with "No", but from the rest of your response it
sounds like you meant "Yes".)
steve
response 47 of 83: Mark Unseen   May 18 22:37 UTC 1999

   No, I meant no. ;-)

   I bet that this will use less power that our power conditioner currently
consumes.  If thats right--or if it uses more power--then it will effect
our usage stats.

   I should have worded that better, upon reading it again.
scg
response 48 of 83: Mark Unseen   May 18 23:04 UTC 1999

Mary's question may have been related to rewiring, adding a 220 V outlet, etc.
davel
response 49 of 83: Mark Unseen   May 19 01:35 UTC 1999

That's what I understood her to mean.  Service, not usage.
 0-24   25-49   50-74   75-83       
Response Not Possible: You are Not Logged In
 

- Backtalk version 1.3.30 - Copyright 1996-2006, Jan Wolter and Steve Weiss