You are not logged in. Login Now
 0-24   25-49   50-74   75-99   100-124   125-149   150-174   175-199   200-224 
 225-249   250-274   275-299   300-324   325-349   350-374   375-399   400-424   425-449 
 450-474   475-499   500-524   525-526       
 
Author Message
25 new of 526 responses total.
jadecat
response 175 of 526: Mark Unseen   Feb 27 19:51 UTC 2006

resp:174 It's only abortion if you consider a fertilized egg that has
NOT implanted to be the begining of life. That particular scenario is
the last ditch for hormonal birth control anyway- as there are two steps
prior to that which would prevent an egg from getting fertilized. 

It seems to me that most pro-lifers against Plan B have no CLUE what the
science behind it is.
slynne
response 176 of 526: Mark Unseen   Feb 27 19:53 UTC 2006

They say it is an abortion but it isnt. Those same people often claim 
that all hormonal birth control causes abortion as well as other 
methods such as an IUD. I think it is important to get on the same page 
about when pregnancy actually starts. Generally, the beginning of 
pregnancy is when the egg attaches itself to the uterine wall. Many 
right to lifers, however, seem to believe that it begins with 
fertilization of the egg or even before (you might laugh at the whole 
MOnty Python "every sperm is sacred" but they were making a parody of 
an actual view held by many people in the Right-to-Life crowd). 

(Anne keeps slipping in, saying what I planned on saying. I am going to 
post my post anyways though even though it might look like I am copying 
her.) 
marcvh
response 177 of 526: Mark Unseen   Feb 27 19:55 UTC 2006

Yes, some people like to define words like "abortion" to mean that
which suits their argument rather than using the generally accepted
definition.  It makes conversation impossible, so such people are
annoying.

The "slut haters" idea is a hypothesis which attempts to explain the
views of pro-lifers who think that abortion is OK if it's the result of
rape or incest.  If someone can present a better hypothesis then that's
fine, but so far I haven't heard one.
tod
response 178 of 526: Mark Unseen   Feb 27 19:58 UTC 2006

These people using the bible to defend their foetus is a human life argument
are of the same ilk that used the bible to defend owning slaves.  
bible bible bible bible bible bible bible bible babble bible babble babble
happyboy
response 179 of 526: Mark Unseen   Feb 27 20:01 UTC 2006

whah do yew hate th' bobble?
bru
response 180 of 526: Mark Unseen   Feb 27 20:05 UTC 2006

All you have to do is get the Religious pro-lifers to agree that life begins
when the bible says it does, when the feotus starts producing blood!  Then
you can dispense the day after pill and the other methods without fear of
ending a life.
nharmon
response 181 of 526: Mark Unseen   Feb 27 20:11 UTC 2006

> It seems to me that most pro-lifers against Plan B have no CLUE what 
> the science behind it is.

I think that is a better explaination of that side of the argument 
than "oh, they're just jealous cuz they dont have SEX...slut haters!"

I consider myself pro-life, but am not against early pregnancy 
termination, birth control, Plan B, sex education in schools, condom 
dispensers, etc. I simply don't see an unborn human life as being less 
like an infant, and more like a pimple.
jadecat
response 182 of 526: Mark Unseen   Feb 27 20:38 UTC 2006

resp:181 Most people have their 'hot points' or topics that cause the
fury first- then the thinking. This happens to be one for me. ;) I do
think that many of the more vocal pro-lifers do have issues with women,
hatred/fear/jealousy, combinations therein perhaps. 

There also seems to be a trend to dscount scientific information. So
they don't bother to learn anything about it. I also think that the
numbers regarding late-term abortions are inflated by the pro-life side
of things. I know one person who had a late-second trimester abortion.
In that case she was so a- irregular that she didn't know she was
pregnant right away, and b- sure that the fetus was harmed by the
activities that took place before she even knew she was pregnant.

There are also very few women who have no negative feelings regarding an
abortion they've had. If it is as easy as popping a pimple- perhaps they
wouldn't be the best parents in the world anyway...
marcvh
response 183 of 526: Mark Unseen   Feb 27 20:39 UTC 2006

So you're a pro-choice person who, for some reason, is uncomfortable
with that label and you prefer to call yourself pro-life even though you
think that most abortions should remain legal.  I find that weird and
confusing.
cyklone
response 184 of 526: Mark Unseen   Feb 27 20:42 UTC 2006

Jep, your limited comprehension skills are slipping further. My example 
about alcohol was a waitron, not a bartender. And the scientology 
reference was based on that religion's frequent and recent public 
statements against the drugs I described, so I fail to see how it is silly 
(BTW, implying Mormons don't believe in prescription drug use is far 
sillier). My point, for those like you who seem unable to grasp what 
others readily see, is that even if you put aside the issue of whether the 
goverment should compel companies to dispense certain drugs, the "get out 
of work free" exemption based on relgious beliefs creates a ridiculous 
burden on employers. It basically says employees can use their religion to 
dictate the terms of their employment. Are you saying you support that? 

Those who claim companies shouldn't be burdened with mandatory dispensing 
laws should also, if they are intellectually honest, recognize that the 
so-called "religious freedom" laws impose burdens at least as great on 
those employers whose rights they claim to support.
nharmon
response 185 of 526: Mark Unseen   Feb 27 20:49 UTC 2006

> So you're a pro-choice person <snip>

Feel free to label me all you want Marc.
tod
response 186 of 526: Mark Unseen   Feb 27 21:20 UTC 2006

re #180
 All you have to do is get the Religious pro-lifers to agree that life begins
 when the bible says it does, when the feotus starts producing blood! 
You know that's bullshit, Bruce.
Life begins with the first breath.
Genesis 2:7 "..formed man from the dust of the ground, and breathed into his
nostrils the breath of life; and man became a living soul."

You get a birth certificate when you are born and breath.  
nharmon
response 187 of 526: Mark Unseen   Feb 27 21:27 UTC 2006

Fetuses breath amniotic fluid to flex their lungs. So there you go.
edina
response 188 of 526: Mark Unseen   Feb 27 21:27 UTC 2006

There we go what?  
kingjon
response 189 of 526: Mark Unseen   Feb 27 21:43 UTC 2006

#186: Not that I hold the position myself, but that is wide open to the obvious
criticism that *Adam's* life began with his first breath, but he wasn't born.

Birth certificates have nothing to do with when life begins; you have a birth
certificate when you are born alive. Breathing is one of the evidences of life
but does not define it any more than "talk-and-build-a-fire" defines sentience.
marcvh
response 190 of 526: Mark Unseen   Feb 27 21:50 UTC 2006

I'd like to see Nathan go to a pro-life rally and talk to some real 
pro-lifers, where he can tell them that he thinks that early term
abortions (which is something like 98% of them) should be considered
legally and morally OK.  Do you think they would label him pro-life?
happyboy
response 191 of 526: Mark Unseen   Feb 27 21:55 UTC 2006

bru: book, chapter, verse, AND version of the bobble, please.
slynne
response 192 of 526: Mark Unseen   Feb 27 21:55 UTC 2006

hell, I would like to see him go to a pro-life rally and say that he 
thinks that *birth-control* is ok 
happyboy
response 193 of 526: Mark Unseen   Feb 27 22:02 UTC 2006

nharmon makes the baby jesus fetus cry.


><
--  <--- stern republican look.
jep
response 194 of 526: Mark Unseen   Feb 27 22:03 UTC 2006

I really wonder, am I perceived as a "slut hater"?  I keep addressing 
that accusation (and variations on it), because people keep posting 
about how all anti-abortion advocates are of that mindset.
happyboy
response 195 of 526: Mark Unseen   Feb 27 22:04 UTC 2006

i think you hate poor people,  passively anyway.
tod
response 196 of 526: Mark Unseen   Feb 27 22:20 UTC 2006

re #189
 Birth certificates have nothing to do with when life begins; you have a birth
 certificate when you are born alive.
Clear as mud, right? Born ALIVE.  That means Living aka LIFE.
Before a birth, the woman gets to decide.  Its that simple.
Live with it.
scholar
response 197 of 526: Mark Unseen   Feb 27 22:55 UTC 2006

i hate poor people.  :(
happyboy
response 198 of 526: Mark Unseen   Feb 27 22:57 UTC 2006

yeah...:(
marcvh
response 199 of 526: Mark Unseen   Feb 27 23:09 UTC 2006

Re #194: who said that "all" anti-abortion advocates are slut-haters?
Certainly not me.  I said "most" and I explained how I reached that 
conclusion.
 0-24   25-49   50-74   75-99   100-124   125-149   150-174   175-199   200-224 
 225-249   250-274   275-299   300-324   325-349   350-374   375-399   400-424   425-449 
 450-474   475-499   500-524   525-526       
Response Not Possible: You are Not Logged In
 

- Backtalk version 1.3.30 - Copyright 1996-2006, Jan Wolter and Steve Weiss