|
Grex > Glb > #48: Transgender issues | |
|
| Author |
Message |
keesan
|
|
Transgender issues
|
Jun 28 21:19 UTC 1999 |
This item is for discussing transgender issues. Not just for people who feel
they were born into the wrong sex body, but for all of us. Are there ways
in which you feel you fit better into the opposite mold? Do you have
interests or talents that are not expected of your sex (taxi driving for
women, artistic talent for men, or whatever)? Do you have a personality that
you could better express if you were the opposite sex? Do you ever wish
people would treat you as the opposite sex gets treated? If you had a choice
of which sex body to be reborn into, would it be the same one you have now?
Do you sometimes feel that you have to act a certain way because it is
expected of you due to your chromosomes, but would rather not? I am
particularly interested in whether bisexual people act much differently
depending on which sex they are with? Would a bi woman act more 'manly' when
with a woman?
|
| 54 responses total. |
lumen
|
|
response 1 of 54:
|
Jun 28 21:43 UTC 1999 |
I have had but few experiences with a guy, and I don't think bi men
really switch gender personality depending on the sex they are with.
|
lumen
|
|
response 2 of 54:
|
Jun 29 21:37 UTC 1999 |
We have an interesting society that is continually trying to change and
reinvent itself. It is easier than ever before to challenge the gender
roles placed on us by the established rules of that society-- some roles
that are very strong and firmly entrenched. Yet some say we in the U.S.
lead the world in feminist causes. We're probably the only nation as
well that started a men's movement that questioned modern roles of man.
It is probably the most difficult for those who are transgendered/
transsexual since they have made a change, or are in the process of
making a change to their biological bodies to better fit their inner
selves. The transitional process is probably the hardest, since our
society doesn't have a traditional role for them.
Transgendered people are also hit hard by violence, or "hate crimes."
Most assailants are heterosexual men, if I remember right.
I think Sindi is raising some good issues: perhaps someday our society
will come to the point where social roles will be decided individually
rather than by consensus, and gender distinction will be de-emphasized.
Or perhaps the opposite will happen..
|
keesan
|
|
response 3 of 54:
|
Jun 30 14:49 UTC 1999 |
I expect that most transgendered people are not undergoing or even considering
surgery. They just feel like their body does not match the sex that they are.
Sort of like being forced to wear clothing that sends the wrong message. You
have the choice of changing the message or not expressing the true you. We
probably all feel this way to some extent, and I would not be surprised if
glb people are farther from the norms than others.
|
lumen
|
|
response 4 of 54:
|
Jun 30 21:36 UTC 1999 |
resp:3 Well, of course, I would bet it's because it is sooo expensive
and the surgery is practiced mostly in Sweden. I doubt that many have
the resources to cover it; for insurance to foot the bill, they must
have a psychiatrist explain that a sex change would be in the best
interest of mental health for the person. Even the hormones are
outrageously expensive, and hormonal therapy has to be given first.
I only saw one transgendered person in my hometown. I guessed the
person was taking hormones, since the person gradually developed some
curves and breasts (transgendered biological male). I'd seen this
person on the bus sometimes, and my homophobic assistant manager at the
Sbarro's Italian Eatery I worked at pointed out that the person worked
at the optical store nearby the mall food court we were located in.
This is why I say I think transgendered people are suffering more stigma
than the glb folk; it's harder to blend in.
|
jazz
|
|
response 5 of 54:
|
Jun 30 23:05 UTC 1999 |
They've been doing transgender surgery in the 'States for years now
- around the time that people had to go to Sweden for it, they also had to
go to Mexico for abortions. :)
I was surprised to learn one of my old acquaintances is now
transgendered (he's straight, or she's gay, depending on how you want to look
at it).
Our society does have defined sex-roles, but that's largely an artifact
of our culture - other societies have differing sex-roles, and it's not
uncommon to see things, from an American perspective, reversed - in Iran men
are often phsyically affectionate, are expected to be openly emotional, and
write poetry, while women are encouraged to not show emotion and to be more
practical, for instance.
So I wonder, among the TGers, if they're in rebellion to the defined
sex roles - as I am in a number of ways - in the sense that they feel closer
to the "other" sex role, or an uncomfortableness with their own bodies, which
is a different sort of ailment.
|