|
Grex > Coop8 > #38: Choosing Grex's medium-range priorities | |
|
| Author |
Message |
popcorn
|
|
Choosing Grex's medium-range priorities
|
Mar 12 14:28 UTC 1996 |
With the long-term planning meeting coming up later this month, this seems
an opportune time to ask on-line: What would you like to see as Grex's
priorities in the coming months? Item 37 talks about the merits of Usenet
news in particular. What other things do or don't you want to see Grex focus
on?
|
| 32 responses total. |
popcorn
|
|
response 1 of 32:
|
Mar 12 14:29 UTC 1996 |
My choices:
* Move to the Sun 4, and then start investigating even faster CPUs.
* Get an ISDN net connection.
* Not sure where I stand on Usenet news. It sure seemed to draw in
money, but I'm not sure that's an important consideration.
|
robh
|
|
response 2 of 32:
|
Mar 12 16:31 UTC 1996 |
Not sure that money is a consideration? I'd much rather see us get
Usenet than (for instance) limit the access of non-paying users.
I'd say:
* Move to the Sun 4
* Move to the Sun 4
* Move to the Sun 4
* Move to the Sun 4
* More bandwidth
* Move to the Sun 4
* Move to the Sun 4
* Get the Sun 3 working as a mail machine
* See if we can get gryps to stop crashing
|
steve
|
|
response 3 of 32:
|
Mar 12 17:39 UTC 1996 |
My idea for a priority list
- Get onto the Sun-4
- Get gryps upgraded to the latest FreeBSD that has the serial bugs fixed
- Investigate better bandwidth possibilities
- Get the Sun-3 turned into another Sun-4 (4/200 CPU cards are now selling
for $175 at times--we don't want to be runing two different architectures)
- Get Usenet going again
- Investigate news/mail living on one machine. Maybe get greedy doing mail
Now, several of these are being worked on already, such an looking
into net connections. The only one I'm sure of in priority is #1: getting
to the sun-4
|
kerouac
|
|
response 4 of 32:
|
Mar 12 21:40 UTC 1996 |
I'd like to see the talked about web-based conferencing become
reality and I'd like to see picospan and newuser upgraded in an effort
to overhaul conference presentation, so that more new users know about
the conferences and can more easily create .cflists I'd also like to
see the Intro conf robh proposed. These hardware upgrades are important
but they are not the solution to everything.
|
srw
|
|
response 5 of 32:
|
Mar 13 01:04 UTC 1996 |
I agree with kerouac that there are things we should be doing that
will make the conmferences more attractive. These changes are sorely needed
but don't tend to require money, but rather effort. They are also quite
independent of our hardware limitations and planned upgrades.
However, this is drift. Valerie asked about ideas for how we should spend
money to improve things. Assuming the Sun-4 project is done sucking money
out of our bank account, I think bandwidth is the next thing we should be
spending money on.
|
janc
|
|
response 6 of 32:
|
Mar 13 02:35 UTC 1996 |
Agreed.
|
jazz
|
|
response 7 of 32:
|
Mar 13 06:41 UTC 1996 |
Silly question, but is gryps running gated or routed?
|
popcorn
|
|
response 8 of 32:
|
Mar 13 06:44 UTC 1996 |
Actually, I'm interested in talking about all types of future plans, not just
financial ones. The budget is a major factor in deciding what to do next,
but so is staff time, and other resources. We can throw all kinds of project
ideas in the hopper, then go through the list and figure out which ones are
feasable and desirable.
Other project ideas:
* Moving Grex to a new location
* Putting Grex on a UPS
|
popcorn
|
|
response 9 of 32:
|
Mar 13 06:45 UTC 1996 |
(#7 slipped in. I dunno the answer, but gated doesn't ring any bells, while
routed might, maybe.)
|
ajax
|
|
response 10 of 32:
|
Mar 13 07:02 UTC 1996 |
1. Move Grex to the Sun 4
2. Switch to all 9600 bps lines
3. Move Grex to something faster than the Sun 4 (probably; we'll see!)
4. Get a higher-bandwidth Internet connection
5. Get a UPS
And outside the above priority scheme, move Grex to a new home,
as opportunities arise, and add more dial-in lines as needed to
keep the lines free most of the time. (As $'s permit, of course.)
Depending on prices, it seems to me we may be better off getting
a faster CPU for Grex and keeping mail on the same system as it
is now...probably simpler, and possibly cheaper. Or maybe the
Sun 4 will obviate the need for splitting mail off on a separate
machine, who knows!
|
srw
|
|
response 11 of 32:
|
Mar 13 07:11 UTC 1996 |
I'm with Rob on his 1 and 2 priorities (I had forgotten about the need to
upgrade the modems). In fact #2 should read 14,400, not 9600.
I part company with the ordering of 3 and 4. I think a faster net connection
will be more important than a faster computer, once we're on the sun-4.
|
mdw
|
|
response 12 of 32:
|
Mar 13 09:56 UTC 1996 |
I'd like to see us get keberos or something like it up, so that we can
sensibly manage a distributed computing environment without needing to
compromise on security issues.
gryps uses static routes. Networking-wise, we have a really simple
configuration. If it goes to the 152.160.30.* subnet, it goes to our
ethernet, otherwise, it goes out our PPP link. This never changes, so
is ideally suited for static routes. ISP's that offer PPP & have
multiple redundant network connections have a strong need for some sort
of dynamic routing protocol, such as RIP or GATE, but these introduce a
whole host of new isues, such as protecting routers against bogus or
malicious routing information. So, it's really quite fortuitous that we
don't have any of those needs, and we count our blessings each time we
think of our nice simple static routes.
|
gregc
|
|
response 13 of 32:
|
Mar 13 12:08 UTC 1996 |
Based on a number of tests that I've run, I think the Sun-4(with it's
current 4200 CPU board) is going to be very satisfactory. Although, from
a strict computational single-user-dumb-benchmark viewpoint the 4200
is only about as fast as a 486 running at 20mhz, when it comes to multi-
user performance, the entire Sparc/VME/hardware setup has a number of
enhancements that a PC class machine can't touch. So I think people
are going to be pleased with the performance once we're on the new
machine. We should see about a 3 to 4 times speed increase over the Sun-3
and a tremendous increase in reliability.
Also, when we do decide we need more CPU, we have a very painless
upgrade path. We can buy a Sun 4400 CPU board and new memory cards.
This is a standard supported upgrade path. We'd just shut the system down,
pull out the current CPU and memory boards, slide in the new CPU and
memory baords and start the system back up. Total upgrade time: about
1 hour. We wouldn't need to repeat the 8 month upgrade that the current
machine took, becuase we wouldn't need to change *any* of the software.
At current prices, we could get a 4400 and 96 megs of memory for under
$2500. But I expect that by the time we need it, say a year and a half or
2 years down the road, the price will be more like $1200.
|
ajax
|
|
response 14 of 32:
|
Mar 22 17:21 UTC 1996 |
I wonder if it's worth considering getting a SPARCserver 2 instead
of a Sun 4/400. It's not VME, but that doesn't seem like that important
a consideration except for memory, which would need to be replaced
anyway. It uses SIMMs and needs a memory card for above 64M RAM,
but with used SIMMs hitting $12/meg now and falling fast, it might be
a viable alternative to the still cheaper RAM used in the Sun 4's, by
the time Grex is ready for another upgrade. Lower power usage might
provide a significant savings.
Price-wise, I've seen bare SS2s for $500. Sun 4/470s and 490s seem
*much* rarer, and I don't know what they sell for. Are SS2's as
reliable as Sun 3's and 4's? A comparison of some system features:
3/260 4/260 4/470 SS2 (4/75)
4 MIPS 10 MIPS 22 MIPS 28.5 MIPS
8 hardware contexts 16 HCs 64 HCs 16 HCs
128M physical RAM 128M physical 96M physical 128M physical
VME bus VME bus VME bus SBus
|
ajax
|
|
response 15 of 32:
|
Mar 22 23:33 UTC 1996 |
Say, we just got a CD of FreeBSD 2.0.5 (June 1995, from Walnut Creek)
donated for the JCC sale. I imagine there's a newer version, but shall
I set it aside for upgrading Gryps' OS? Walnut Creek sells the disk for
$40 new.
|
scg
|
|
response 16 of 32:
|
Mar 23 07:39 UTC 1996 |
The current version is 2.1. It's available vi FTP, or I have it on floppies.
|
jazz
|
|
response 17 of 32:
|
Mar 23 15:42 UTC 1996 |
Rob, precisely *where* can you get a SS2 for $500 bare? :)
|
ajax
|
|
response 18 of 32:
|
Mar 23 16:05 UTC 1996 |
I read the ad in misc.forsale.computers.workstation, but I just checked
again and can't find it after a casual search. If you're interested in
getting it, let me know and I'll look harder.
I was checking on the prices for Sun 4/200 boards, as the price came up
during the meeting. David Case (dcase@case.com), a used workstation dealer,
is selling them for $100. I don't remember if Grex uses 10Base-T, but he's
got $20 SynOptic 508A 10B-T transceivers, too. "Modern looking little
Ethernet transceivers with lots of little indicator lites."
|
steve
|
|
response 19 of 32:
|
Mar 23 16:30 UTC 1996 |
I don't know how many slots there are on the SS2, but using 1M simms
isn't likely to get us much, I don't think. This isn't to say that we
shouldn't look at the SS2 however. I'm pretty sure you can do way above
96M on the 4/400 series, too. Note the number of hardware contexts: thats
what we really want. 22Mips with 64 hc's will beat out 28Mips with only
16hc's, for our purposes.
Bring the CD rom along for sale--we can get newer copies electronically.
|
ajax
|
|
response 20 of 32:
|
Mar 23 18:27 UTC 1996 |
Ahso, maybe the 96M on a 4/400 is on the board itself. I just saw a 4/470
for sale with 196M, 128 of it on a single card.
|
steve
|
|
response 21 of 32:
|
Mar 24 00:45 UTC 1996 |
How much was it? Might want to start entering those as you see 'em,
so we can start tracking their fall in price...
|
ajax
|
|
response 22 of 32:
|
Mar 24 06:43 UTC 1996 |
From memory, the 4/470 with 192MB RAM and other incidentals
was $4000. Another person was selling a 4/470 with 32MB RAM,
1GB disk, and I think monitor & keyboard for $850, but with
shipping estimated at $240(!) if you want the case & monitor.
|
selena
|
|
response 23 of 32:
|
Mar 24 17:17 UTC 1996 |
Well, you guys had $100.00 toward a UPS for almost a year, and sat on it..
|
janc
|
|
response 24 of 32:
|
Mar 24 18:57 UTC 1996 |
We do that a lot, I'm afraid. We aren't always good at getting things done
in a timely fashion.
|