|
Grex > Coop7 > #21: Letting people know about limitations on Grex | |
|
| Author |
Message |
steve
|
|
Letting people know about limitations on Grex
|
Mar 19 20:51 UTC 1995 |
In the last week or so, I've found no less than twenty
SPARC binaries, and a dozen various flavors of MUD's that
people have been trying to compile here.
Because of this, and the fact that staff is spending more and
more time dealing with things like really large mail files, I put
a new section into newuser, talking about limitation on Grex.
We've talked about this a little before, but in the typical
Grexian fashion didn't do much about it. I've taken the liberty
of adding this now, and we can talk about the specifics about it
here and make whatever modifications we deen necessary.
Although it's beyond the scope of this item, we have what is
turning into a serious problem on Grex, namely how it's being
pulled in every direction, limit wise.
This text is a reasonable first step I believe, but others might
want to change it. I've kept it as short as possible, but its still
34 lines. I don't see how we can shorten it and still make it useful,
but maybe we can. I'm very much aware of the "overload" factor we
have in newuser now, but talking about limits has to be there, since
it is the one document that new people here have any chance of
automatically seeing.
...So, commants?
Limititations of Grex
(or, The Tragedy of the Electronic Commons)
Because of the popularity of Grex, we're *swamped* with all the
traffic going over our Internet link. This link is *one* 28.8Kbps
modem, over which people telnet in, mail flows, FTP, Lynx, and all
the other Internet applications share (or rather, fight over). We're
sorry to have to talk about restrictions, but we need your help!
Grex is primarily a computer conferencing system. We ARE NOT
AN INTERNET PROVIDER. This means that we aren't a good place to
store files, do FTPs from, etc. Please do try out the conferences;
we have many topics ranging from the silly to the serious.
You cannot use most Internet services (telnet, ftp, etc.) once
you've made an account here. This is to prevent cyberslime from
using Grex as a jumping point to other systems for neferious purposes.
You must become a member in order to have access to these programs.
Bringing over your own copy of telnet/ftp/whatever, will not work.
,p
We need your help to keep Grex's Intenet connection working at
anything close to a reasonable speed. There are three main areas
of concern. We'd really appreciate it if:
- You do not subscribe to large mailing lists! The staff of Grex
have to spend too much time unsubscribing people from lists that
they've forgotten, such that LARGE piles of mail sit waiting...
Mail is an incredible resource pig on Grex.
- You do not store, mail or FTP GIF, JPG or other data files here.
Because of our slow Internet link, each transfer slows everything
else down just a little more.
- For programmers: Please don't bring over large software packages
without talking to staff first. Anything net related won't run
once you've compiled it anyway. We can't run MUDs or other such
things here, because we just don't have the CPU or bandwidth for
them. Also, Grex is not a SPARC--so it's doubly useless to bring
SPARC programs over here. ;-)
Thanks, from all the staff at Grex!
|
| 102 responses total. |
steve
|
|
response 1 of 102:
|
Mar 19 20:53 UTC 1995 |
I'm sorry if people think I've overstepped by bounds here. But I
thought it was important to come up with something quickly, now. The
actual content can change as people see fit, but we need to say
something. We've had 75M of disk dissapear in the last week. Obviously
a lot of it is general things, but I've found many largish tar
files and talked to a lot of people lately about them.
...Would that we had a T1 link of our own...
|
remmers
|
|
response 2 of 102:
|
Mar 19 20:59 UTC 1995 |
The reason for disallowing outgoing internet access to non-members
is not "to prevent cyberslime from using Grex as a jumping point...",
so that sentence should be deleted.
|
steve
|
|
response 3 of 102:
|
Mar 19 21:09 UTC 1995 |
Oh? It wasn't? I thought that was one of the main reasons, along
with the fact that a whole lot of people would try.
But it is a bit negative. Unless others come to its defense by
tonight it'll be history.
|
chelsea
|
|
response 4 of 102:
|
Mar 19 21:27 UTC 1995 |
This response has been erased.
|
scg
|
|
response 5 of 102:
|
Mar 19 21:50 UTC 1995 |
I thought verification was to prevent cyberslime from using Grex
as a jumping point, and the membership requirement was for bandwidth
reasons. Also, I was under the impression that, while telnet and FTP, and
maybe a few other things, are restricted for bandwidth reasons, most of
the Internet services Grex provides for members are locked out due to
staff not having had time to open them up yet. Remember that vote we had
last summer?
Apart from that quibble, it looks good. I agree with STeve that
newuser pretty much has to be the place for it.
|
robh
|
|
response 6 of 102:
|
Mar 19 22:02 UTC 1995 |
Thank Goddess you put this in, steve. I had no idea the MUD
situation has gotten so bad. Were people telnetting into Grex
on a specific port to access these MUDs, or were they using
Grex accounts to access it? (Assuming you know...)
I often get people asking me for help in compiling MUDs and
such here, I tend to be pretty straightforward with them about
why we can't do it. I'm glad that everyone will get this message.
Maybe somthing should be put in the motd so all of our current
users will know about this?
|
nephi
|
|
response 7 of 102:
|
Mar 19 23:03 UTC 1995 |
Hey, I thought we didn't have access to newuser so that we could make
changes to it!
|
scg
|
|
response 8 of 102:
|
Mar 19 23:33 UTC 1995 |
I think we have access to the configuration files, but not the source
code. Somebody correct me if that's wrong.
|
popcorn
|
|
response 9 of 102:
|
Mar 20 02:29 UTC 1995 |
Yup, we have access to the configuration files, not the source code.
STeve changed a configuration file.
Thanks for doing this, STeve -- it was much needed.
Re internet connection restrictions: I was under the impression that
this was *both* to prevent system cracker types from using Grex as a
way to cover their tracks, and also because Grex doesn't have the
bandwidth to be a free internet provider to everybody in the world.
FYI: The line with the ",p" on it tells newuser to pause there and
ask the user to press Enter to continue.
|
steve
|
|
response 10 of 102:
|
Mar 20 05:09 UTC 1995 |
Yes, it was just a change to a config file. Last time I checked
however, I had access to the source to newuser in UM IFS space, so
access to newuser really isn't the point, its where do we put it here
until we get the disk problem fixed.
I was really suprised to see the increase of large things here.
and thats what prompted me to write the limit blurb.
|
steve
|
|
response 11 of 102:
|
Mar 20 05:29 UTC 1995 |
OK, here is the new version that will be in the config file in about
five minutes.
Limititations of Grex
(or, The Tragedy of the Electronic Commons)
Because of the popularity of Grex, we're *swamped* with all the
traffic going over our Internet link. This link is *one* 28.8Kbps
modem, over which people telnet in, mail flows, FTP, Lynx, and all
the other Internet applications share (or rather, fight over). We're
sorry to have to talk about restrictions, but we need your help!
Grex is primarily a computer conferencing system. We ARE NOT
AN INTERNET PROVIDER. This means that we aren't a good place to
store files, do FTPs from, etc. Please do try out the conferences;
we have many topics ranging from the silly to the serious.
You will not be able to use most Internet services (telnet, FTP,
etc.) once you've made an account here. You must first become a
member in order to have access to these programs. Bringing over your
own copy of telnet/ftp/whatever, will not work.
,p
We need your help to keep Grex's Intenet connection working at
anything close to a reasonable speed. There are three main areas
of concern. We'd really appreciate it if:
- You do not subscribe to large mailing lists! The staff of Grex
have to spend too much time unsubscribing people from lists that
people have forgotten, such that LARGE piles of mail sit, waiting...
Mail is an incredible resource pig on Grex.
- You do not store, mail or FTP GIF, JPG or other data files here.
Because of our slow Internet link, each transfer slows everything
else down just a little more.
- For programmers: Please don't bring over large software packages
without talking to staff first. Anything net related won't run
once you've compiled it anyway. We can't run MUDs or other such
things here, because we just don't have the CPU or bandwidth for
them. Also, Grex is not a SPARC--so it's doubly useless to bring
SPARC programs over here. ;-)
Thanks, from all the staff at Grex!
|
gregc
|
|
response 12 of 102:
|
Mar 20 07:43 UTC 1995 |
Actually I too was under the impression that internet access was dissallowed
"to prevent cyberslime from using grex as a jumping point...".
However, I don't like the wording. Steve your constant use of the phrase
"cyberslime" in mail and official postings is one fo those items of
folksieness and familiarity I was complaining about. You invented that
word and you are making the (wrong) assumption that another person will
either know what it means or will be able to grok it from context. Some
people undoubtably will, but I'm also certain that it will also promote
confusion and MIS-understanding in alot of other peoples minds. Please
try to keep the use of compter slang and techspeak to a minimum, I hate to
break this too you, but most people havn't spent 20 years living in the
computer world. :-)
|
srw
|
|
response 13 of 102:
|
Mar 20 07:54 UTC 1995 |
I agree with Greg on that score.
Similarly, I would change the wording "resource pig" to something less
informal. Perhaps "Mail consumes a large percentage of the systems resources."
I think it is OK for people to subscribe to mailing lists if they read
them, though. The limitation sounds a little too harsh to me.
|
remmers
|
|
response 14 of 102:
|
Mar 20 11:37 UTC 1995 |
Hmm. I thought that the main reason we limited outgoing internet
access was the link bandwidth was too small to support unlimited
access to it, and not because of "slimey" uses only.
Anyway, I thought the wording was too negative and prone to mis-
understanding, so I'm glad it's gone.
|
chelsea
|
|
response 15 of 102:
|
Mar 20 13:32 UTC 1995 |
But if the reason really is to prevent "slimey" types from running
rampant then that's good news as putting a form of verifcation in
place will solve the problem. I can't imagine why sending money
would make us feel more secure than having a copy of good ID.
|
steve
|
|
response 16 of 102:
|
Mar 20 15:18 UTC 1995 |
3rd cut:
Limititations of Grex
(or, The Tragedy of the Electronic Commons)
Because of the popularity of Grex, we're *swamped* with all the
traffic going over our Internet link. This link is *one* 28.8Kbps
modem, over which people telnet in, mail flows, FTP, Lynx, and all
the other Internet applications share (or rather, fight over). We're
sorry to have to talk about restrictions, but we need your help!
Grex is primarily a computer conferencing system. We ARE NOT
AN INTERNET PROVIDER. This means that we aren't a good place to
store files, do FTPs from, etc. Please do try out the conferences;
we have many topics ranging from the silly to the serious.
You will not be able to use most Internet services (telnet, FTP,
etc.) once you've made an account here. You must first become a
member in order to have access to these programs. Bringing over your
own copy of telnet/ftp/whatever, will not work.
,p
We need your help to keep Grex's Intenet connection working at
anything close to a reasonable speed. There are three main areas
of concern--we'd really appreciate it if:
- You do not subscribe to large mailing lists and then forget about
them! The staff of Grex spends a lot of time unsubscribing people
from lists that aren't read. If you decide to leave Grex, *please*
unsubscribe yourself from the lists you are on. Mail is now the
single most resource intensive application on Grex. Your help in
curbing "mail bloat" is sincerely appreciated! If you create a
".forward" file here, do remember that all the mail you get on Grex
will wind up having twice the impact on Grex's Internet link.
- You do not store, mail or FTP GIF, JPG or other data files here.
Because of our slow Internet link, each transfer slows everything
else down just a little more.
- For programmers: Please don't bring over large software packages
without talking to staff first. Anything net related won't run
once you've compiled it anyway. We can't run MUDs or other such
things here, because we just don't have the CPU or net bandwidth
for them. Also, Grex is not a SPARC--so it's doubly useless to
bring SPARC programs over here. ;-)
Thanks, from all the staff at Grex!
|
gregc
|
|
response 17 of 102:
|
Mar 20 15:32 UTC 1995 |
I'm also happy to see the statement that we are primarily a conferencing
system, not an Internet provider. I've wanted that to be in there for a
long time.
|
srw
|
|
response 18 of 102:
|
Mar 20 15:45 UTC 1995 |
Yes, I really like this statement now. Typo: Intenet
Thanks STeve.
|
popcorn
|
|
response 19 of 102:
|
Mar 20 19:55 UTC 1995 |
Basically I like it a lot. Minor quibbles:
1) The second page is more than a screenful.
2) I'd capitalize the entire word "We" in the sentence "We ARE NOT AN...."
3) The sentence "twice the impact on the internet link" could use some
clarification so it's clear you're talking about a *negative* impact.
Again, thanks for putting this into newuser. It's much needed.
|
steve
|
|
response 20 of 102:
|
Mar 20 20:47 UTC 1995 |
OK, changes made: 1) fixed Intenet spelling, 2) the WE ARE NOT AN
INTERNET PROVIDER has a WE in it now, and is on its own line for clairty,
3) the comment about .forwards having twice the impact has a little more
explaination, 4) the second screen is now less than one screenfull.
|
lilmo
|
|
response 21 of 102:
|
Mar 21 02:23 UTC 1995 |
I don't know if anyone else noticed this, but the wording of the "list"
items on the second/third pages seems a bitharsh and accusatory to me,
i.e., my eye jumps to "You do not ...", and it MIGHT be better to have
"--we'd really appreciate it if" cut uot, and have each list item start
instead with "Please do not [or don't] ..." This will also be more
consistent with the third list item.
Just my $.02-worth.
|
steve
|
|
response 22 of 102:
|
Mar 21 04:27 UTC 1995 |
I understand what you're saying. It is negative, but then again,
perhaps the negativism is a good thing? We're *really* getting swammped
these days. Part of me thinks that its a reasonable thing to state it
nicely, though loudly. The other part says make it nicer. I don't know.
|
nephi
|
|
response 23 of 102:
|
Mar 21 07:39 UTC 1995 |
Are we really *so* swamped? Grex is probably ten times faster than
when I first logged on.
|
gregc
|
|
response 24 of 102:
|
Mar 21 08:13 UTC 1995 |
I saw keep the tone a tad harsh. Maybe it will stick in peoples minds
that way.
|