You are not logged in. Login Now
 0-24   25-49   50-60        
 
Author Message
popcorn
Change default picospan mailer to pine? Mark Unseen   Nov 21 07:43 UTC 1994

I'd like to change Picospan's default mail program from a combination
of the built-in Picospan mailer and "mail", to "pine".  Also, I'm going
to change newuser to default to "vt100" instead of "dumb" terminal type.

Is anybody going to have a problem with this?
60 responses total.
carson
response 1 of 60: Mark Unseen   Nov 21 07:52 UTC 1994

<whine> <whine>

not I.
rcurl
response 2 of 60: Mark Unseen   Nov 21 08:12 UTC 1994

Just those with dumb terminals and a love of "mail". But the majority
will bless you.
kentn
response 3 of 60: Mark Unseen   Nov 21 08:31 UTC 1994

While you're changing, get pine 3.91.  It kicks the version Grex
has right on out the door.  Quite a few shortcut/speedup features
in the menus now.
popcorn
response 4 of 60: Mark Unseen   Nov 21 08:51 UTC 1994

Oh yeah, that!  It's on the staff To Do list.
Do you know off the top of your head where the ftp site for it is?
robh
response 5 of 60: Mark Unseen   Nov 21 11:51 UTC 1994

Maybe an explanation should be put in newuser?  Or you can send
some vt100 escape codes to the screen, and ask, "Did you see a
bunch of funny [[ characters just now?"  I'd hate to set the
newusers up on a vt100 if they can't use it, and don't know how
to change it.
remmers
response 6 of 60: Mark Unseen   Nov 21 12:04 UTC 1994

How does newuser handle terminal type choices these days?   What does
the user see?  (It's been a while since I've run it.)
steve
response 7 of 60: Mark Unseen   Nov 21 14:03 UTC 1994

   newuser still gives the userr billions and billions of choices
when 1) most people don't really understand about them, 2) the vast
majority use something which is inherently ANSI-ish, 3) they don't
even know what a terminal type *means*.
   Newuser should have been changed long ago.  I believe john created
something called ansi-simple, or something like that for use in this
situation?
popcorn
response 8 of 60: Mark Unseen   Nov 21 14:05 UTC 1994

Newuser currently asks people to choose a terminal type.  It tells
people that if they don't know, ansi or vt100 would be good choices.
It offers to try to autodetect your terminal type if you type in a ?
or to list all 350+ terminal types if you type in a ??.  And, finally,
it says that if you just don't get it, press enter to select "dumb"
as your terminal type, and you can come back and change it later since
it doesn't matter all that much.

What I want to change is that last part, where it says to pick dumb
if you don't know what you've got.  I'd like it to select vt100 (or
John's ansi-new or *something* smart) instead of dumb.
popcorn
response 9 of 60: Mark Unseen   Nov 21 14:08 UTC 1994

Incidentally, part of this question is that I'm thinking of making it
a picospan-wide switch from "mail" to "pine".  Is that OK?  Will it
confuse the heck out of people who are used to typing "mail" when they
are in Picospan?
tsty
response 10 of 60: Mark Unseen   Nov 21 15:29 UTC 1994

If the change only would affect newusers, it probably is
a worthwhile change. 
  
If however, I type    mail    which is what I +do+ type, and
I find myself slung up in some weird tree ........<g>
remmers
response 11 of 60: Mark Unseen   Nov 21 17:19 UTC 1994

My gut feeling -- without hard data to back it up -- is that we'd be
better off switching to ansi or vt100 as the default, in preference to
dumb.  Ansi might be a slightly safer default than vt100, as there are
ANSI emulations out there that don't have all the vt100 bells and
whistles.

I replaced the ansi termcap and terminfo descriptions a few months ago
with smarter versions that support text highlighting (boldface, inverse
video, underscore) and cursor keys, and tested the new descriptions
with vi, emacs, and lynx, among other things.  So the ansi description
should provide good support for just about anything anyone can do on
Grex.

Not being a pine user myself, I'll have to accept others' judgements
on whether it's a reasonable default.  People should be warned before
choosing it that you need smart terminal emulation (like, ansi or
vt100 or something comparable) to use it.  Perhaps they should be
prevented from choosing it if they choose "dumb" as their terminal
type.

Current users shouldn't have their mail program changed on them, if
that's the implication of "Picospan-wide".  If people are satisfied
with mail or elm, they should be allowed to keep them without hassle.
scg
response 12 of 60: Mark Unseen   Nov 21 21:32 UTC 1994

There are plenty of other customizations that newuser asks for, so it
shouldn't complicate things too much more to ask people to choose a
mailer, would it?
popcorn
response 13 of 60: Mark Unseen   Nov 21 23:48 UTC 1994

No no.  Asking new users to choose a mailer is not an option right now.
For one, the source is currently off-line where I can't get to it, so
it's easy to change defaults and text screens from the config file (which
is on-line on Grex), but it's difficult to add new questions.  For another,
my impression is that newuser already bombards the new user with an awful
lot of questions they don't understand, and adding a question about a
mailer is only going to make life tougher for new users.  I'd like to see
newuser tend toward fewer questions, not more.

The mailer question I'm asking applies strictly to what happens when
everybody, old user or new, types "mail" at a Picospan prompt. 
If it's a Bad Idea to change that, I'd be willing to see newuser silently
select a mailer for each new person, without asking.
srw
response 14 of 60: Mark Unseen   Nov 22 01:32 UTC 1994

I'm in agreement, Valerie. No more new questions.
If someone's terminal is set to dumb and they type mail at the OK,
your proposed change is problematical. Pine will fail, and they'll
not get told that they now should type !mail. I would like to find a
way to send people to pine, but with less wreckage. You have a good idea -
it's going in the right direction, but needs the rough edges smoothed out.
davel
response 15 of 60: Mark Unseen   Nov 22 01:56 UTC 1994

Maybe a script wrapped around that checks $TERM and calls mail instead if
it's dumb?

And Valerie, this isn't going to preempt "define readmail" and "define
sendmail" settings in people's .cfonce files, is it?  If it overrides
those, I'd say it's a bad idea.  Otherwise go for it.
steve
response 16 of 60: Mark Unseen   Nov 22 03:56 UTC 1994

   Excellent idea, Dave!  Wow.

   I'm for not asking about the mailer, not becuase its another question,
but becuase most people haven't the foggeist what to use if they aren't
familiar with the UNIX environment.  So, I'd say pick elm or pine, which
ever is better for new folks, and go with that.
jfk
response 17 of 60: Mark Unseen   Nov 23 19:23 UTC 1994

pine is at ftp.cac.washington.edu

I had problems within newer versions of pine at 7-bit even settings.
You might want to test that out pretty thoroughly.
remmers
response 18 of 60: Mark Unseen   Nov 25 11:11 UTC 1994

Hmm, yes, I think we will want to be careful about that.  We are running
an older version of pico (the pine editor) precisely because there were
problems running the latest one in a 7-bit environment.
kentn
response 19 of 60: Mark Unseen   Nov 25 21:17 UTC 1994

When are we making the switch to 8N1?  Could make this problem go
away...
gorkon
response 20 of 60: Mark Unseen   Nov 26 12:35 UTC 1994

Good idea, If you are going to make the switch to pine, make pine the current
version, 3.91, and could you also set it up for news, then only one program is
needed for both, and takes the pain(and cost) out of learning new packages.
wh
response 21 of 60: Mark Unseen   Dec 6 09:26 UTC 1994

I looked at the newuser program tonight. It is a lot to digest
for a first session. All of it looked necessary. So I am for not
adding any more questions to the already-burdened first-time user.

I would recommend pine for people just coming into Grex. I tried
it when I first found out about it and have used it ever since.
It is quite friendly to new users.
nephi
response 22 of 60: Mark Unseen   Dec 16 12:31 UTC 1994

I heard that pine was terribly slow.  Was I misinformed?  Also, on m-net, 
where I had my terminal type set to ansi, Pine told me that it required a
more advanced terminal setting in order to run.  

 
remmers
response 23 of 60: Mark Unseen   Dec 16 17:13 UTC 1994

I don't use pine, so I can't comment on its speed.  But the ansi termcap
on grex is a home-grown one that is more capable than the stock ansi
termcap found on most Unix systems; pine should work with it.  So I'd
suggest trying pine on grex and seeing how it goes.
sidhe
response 24 of 60: Mark Unseen   Jan 9 16:53 UTC 1995

        No! Do not change from mail to pine! I cannot stand how long pine takes
        to run, for one thing, and mail is so much easier to check your
        messages with. As for the terminal question, I knew *nothing* about
        unix, or term 
types when I first logged in in october, but it was very clear, and helpful
<newuser, I mean>, and I think switching it would cause more problems than
it solves. For one thing, what if I *am* calling in from a dumb terminal
<which I do, from time to time>.. what then?
 0-24   25-49   50-60        
Response Not Possible: You are Not Logged In
 

- Backtalk version 1.3.30 - Copyright 1996-2006, Jan Wolter and Steve Weiss